10 Best Yogi Berra Baseball Cards To Add To Your Collection

Yogi Berra (1925-2015) is one of the best-known baseball players of his era, with a presence that is still felt today. He was an 18-time All-Star who won 10 World Series championships as a player, which is still the record.

A big personality off the field, he’s also the originator of the phrase, “It ain’t over till it’s over.” He used it to describe the 1973 National League pennant race. His team was a long way behind when he said it and they eventually rallied to win the division title with a game to spare.

A Yankees legend, he also turned out for the Mets in later years. Berra was either a player, coach, or manager in every 13 World Series wins that New York baseball teams recorded from 1947 through 1981. Talk about a good luck charm!

Investment Rating: Buy (4.7 out of 5)
Ownership Disclosure: None
Best Yogi Berra Baseball Card: 1948 Yogi Berra Bowman RC #6 (Shop eBay)

Here’s a rundown of three of the best Yogi Berra baseball cards, looking back through the years at some great vintage sets. There are lots of great options if you’re a Berra fan. The Yankees were huge at the time, while he signed cards after retirement. Regarding the ‘best’ Berra cards, it’s hard to beat anything from the early years. 

 

1948 Yogi Berra Bowman RC #6

SHOP EBAY

You’ll struggle to find pure value better than his 1948 RC. Produced by Bowman, it features a smaller 2 1/16″ by 2 1/2″ black and white photo of Berra in the middle, along with a thin white border. 

73 years on from its original release, it’s almost impossible to find gem mint copies, while it’s a key card from the set, beaten only by the Stan Musial RC. The reverse contains basic information about the player and lists his name as ‘Larry (Yogi) Berra’. You’ll also spot a vintage Bowman Gum advert at the bottom.

It’s a real piece of history and is somewhat underpriced, considering how popular Berra is in mainstream appeal. Given the age, anything above a PSA 6 will cost at least four figures, while only one copy has received a 10 grade from the service.

 

1957 Topps Mickey Mantle & Yogi Berra #407

SHOP EBAY

Yogi and Mickey made the Bronx Bombers into what they are today (with some help from Babe Ruth). The 1957 Topps Yogi Berra Mickey Mantle baseball card is a must-have for the hardcore (and wealthy) NY Yankee baseball card collectors.

Numbered #407 the card pictures Mantle and Berra with bats slung over their shoulders while posing legs up on the steps leading out to the field. One of the more underrated Topps baseball cards and a great buy at the right price.

 

1953 Yogi Berra Topps SP #104

SHOP EBAY

We’ve split two expensive options up neatly, using this colorful card released by Topps in 1953. It features a large profile shot of Berra, although he has a severe expression on his face, which goes against the grain compared to most of his collectibles.

As the follow-up to the famed 1952 Topps set, it’s not as popular but still includes big names like Mickey Mantle and Willie Mays.

The lower-left corner tends to be the source of numerous issues, holding the card back from achieving higher grades. This is due to the red coloring on the name tag at the bottom. 

 

1949 Yogi Berra Bowman RC #60

SHOP EBAY

It might have been released a year after his ‘48 RC, but that hasn’t stopped this Bowman card from becoming another excellent investment option. Advances in technology allowed for the inclusion of color for the first time in Bowman sets; this card is no different. 

A vibrant red makes up the background, contrasted against a large image of a young Berra holding a bat. In a strange design choice, there’s no nameplate at the bottom, as he was included in the first half of the set. However, it does help the card to stand out from the crowd, and there’s no mistaking Berra in the middle.

 

Yogi Berra Baseball Card Value

The most expensive Yogi Berra baseball card is the legendary 1948 Bowman Yogi Berra rookie card #6 (in black and white).

Looking to purchase a Yogi Berra baseball card on eBay but need advice? Contact us at advice@goldcardauctions.com, and we would be more than happy to chat with you.

Berra did manage after his playing career was over. The most expensive Yogi Berra Manager Baseball Card is the 1973 Topps Orange Background #257 Yogi Berra Mets Manager Coaches card.

 

Buyers Guide and Investment Outlook 

The market for older players is generally low-risk, especially when looking at some of the best players from the post-war era. Berra is arguably the most excellent catcher of all time, and it’s hard to find many faults in his legacy. 

With an RC released just a couple of years after WW2, and a career that seems almost ridiculous on paper, Berra has many cards that are slightly underpriced in the present day. Maybe that’s due to the likes of Mantle and co-stealing his thunder ever so slightly, but he still has several options that have stood the test of time.

“We’ve listed many great options available at differing price points above. His RC is the obvious standout, but the inclusion of color in 1949 Bowman sets also helps it to make a mark.” 

As always, we’d look at PSA-graded copies first when buying vintage cards, and we would recommend getting the highest grade that your budget allows. They don’t tend to come up too often, so it’s worth keeping tabs on Berra’s older cards whenever they’re on the market. 

Leave a Reply