3 Best Steve Young Rookie Cards and Worth

Steve Young is a former quarterback who spent 15 seasons in the NFL, winning almost everything in a storied career.

Buy PSA Graded Steve Young Rookie Cards on eBay

After a couple of years with the Los Angeles Express and the Tampa Bay Buccaneers in the defunct United States Football League, he joined the San Francisco 49ers in 1987. The rest is history.

He’s a three-time Super Bowl champion with seven Pro Bowl appearances. Here’s everything you need to know about Young’s best rookie cards, including a checklist and investment advice for the future.

Based on recent auction data, we’ve put together a trio of the most famous Steve Young rookie cards.

 

1986 Steve Young Topps RC #374 (Buy on eBay)

The 1986 Topps has a green and white striped border and is considered his first ‘true’ rookie card. This is because it’s Young’s original NFL option, rather than USFL like the others on this list.

As for value, a BGS 9 sold for just over $150, giving you a better idea of what it’s worth to collectors. The quote on the back reads;

“Steve threw Buccaneers’ longest completion of the 1985 season, a 59-yarder to Kevin House, December 15th. He guided Brigham Young to 11-1 record and a Holiday Bowl win in 1983.”

 

1984 Steve Young USFL Topps RC #52 (Buy on eBay)

From his time in the ill-fated USFL, the 1984 Topps is still worth a decent chunk of change. A PSA 10 grade recently sold for $5,200, attracting 66 bids at auction. It’s the most expensive sale in recent months, while a PSA 8 still went for $274. It features a profile image of Young, staring at the camera with his arms crossed. The reverse notes; 

“Steve set 13 NCAA passing and total offense records at BYU.”

1985 Steve Young Topps USFL RC #65 (Buy on eBay)

The final card on our list is the 1985 Topps. Another USFL option, this card has a red border, white and blue to match the USA’s flag.

A PSA 10 recently went for $222.50, a significant price difference compared to his 1984 card. The back has a simple design, with blue text on a white background. The quote on the reverse reads; 

“Averaged 239.7 yards in total offense per game during 1984.”

 

Checklist

  • 1984 Topps USFL Steve Young RC #52
  • 1985 Topps USFL Steve Young RC #65
  • 1986 Topps Steve Young RC #374
  • 1986 Topps Stickers Steve Young RC #23

 

Value

The most valuable Steve Young rookie card is the 1984 Topps USFL Steve Young RC #52 at high grades (i.e., PSA 10, BGS 9.5, SGC 10).

If you are looking for an estimated value of a Steve Young football card, please email us at value@goldcardauctions.com.

 

Buyers Rating and Risk/Profit Analysis

The legendary 49ers quarterback started with an awful 3-16 record over his first two seasons in the NFL but went on to create his legacy with the franchise in the years that followed.

  • Investment Buyers Rating: Buy (4.1 out of 5)
  • Risk Profit Analysis: Low Risk\Moderate to High Return on Investment (ROI)
  • Best Steve Young RC Investment: 1984 Steve Young USFL Topps RC #52
  • Ownership Disclosure: None

His rookie cards are hot property for 49ers fans, collectors interested in the era or his numerous records from QB.

In later years, the Hall of Famer retired due to concussions, despite being offered a job as the starting quarterback of the Denver Broncos in 1999.

More recently, Young has advocated for everything from a better understanding of brain injuries to supporting LGBTQ students at Brigham Young University.

He doesn’t seem to cause controversy that will lead to a drop in his average rookie card prices, so it looks like a safe investment. 

The 1984 Topps is his most popular rookie card by far, and it’s reflected in the average price and overall condition.

PSA 8s and above could be a decent venture if you’re willing to sit on them for a while, and the others are great if you have a slightly lower budget to work with.

2020 Prizm Football Blaster Box
(BUY ON EBAY)

2020 Mosaic Football Box
(BUY ON EBAY)

2021 Prizm Basketball Box
(BUY ON EBAY)

Leave a Comment