The debate between the Superior Grade Comic (SGC) and Certified Guaranty Company (CGC) grading systems has been ongoing for years. Both are used to determine the overall condition of a comic book and thus its value, but each system approached grading differently. In this article, we’ll explore both systems to help you decide which is best for your collection.
The SGC grading system uses a 10-point scale to judge the condition of a comic book. This system is designed to be more subjective, as it takes into account a variety of factors such as the cover, staples, page quality, and overall wear and tear. For example, an SGC 8.5 is considered to be in Near Mint condition, while an SGC 9 would be Very Fine/Near Mint.
The CGC grading system, on the other hand, is much more technical and formalized. It uses a numerical score from 0-10 to measure the condition of the comic book, but also takes into account factors such as page quality and color retention. A CGC 9.4 is considered to be in Near Mint/Mint condition, while a CGC 9.8 would be Mint.
Ultimately, the decision comes down to personal preference. SGC is more subjective, while CGC is more technical and precise. Also consider that SGC grading costs less than CGC grading, but may not provide as much accuracy in determining a comic’s condition and value.
When it comes to protection, SGC and CGC both offer similar levels of security. Both systems use tamper-proof holders to encase the comic book and prevent any damage from occurring. The holders also provide a buffer against UV light and other environmental factors that can degrade the value of a comic over time. In addition, both systems employ third-party authentication services to verify that the comic is genuine and not a counterfeit.
In the end, it’s up to you to decide which grading system is right for your needs. Consider your budget, how much accuracy you need in determining a comic book’s condition and value, and how much protection you want for your collection.