Randy Poffo Baseball Card – Value, Best Cards, and Investment Outlook


This post contains affiliate links. Read the full disclosure here.

Randy Poffo (1952-2011), better known by his stage name Randy Savage, was one of the most popular wrestlers of all-time.

He’s obviously famous for his career in the ring with the WWE among other organizations, but he also had a brief career in minor league baseball as he tried out for the St. Louis Cardinals and Cincinnati Reds. 

Injuries brought an end to that chapter of his career, while he never managed to make it onto a professionally licensed baseball card with his real name. 

Here’s a list with three of the best Randy Savage cards to make it to market, showing off ‘Macho Man’ in all of his glory.

Best 3 Randy Savage Cards

It’s true that Randy Poffo, the baseball player, never appeared on a baseball card. We’d all love for it to be true, but for whatever reason, he wasn’t drafted in 1971, and also turned down a scholarship offer from Arizona State which could have provided a path to the big time.

Upon his death in 2011 he appeared on just 103 trading cards in the Beckett database, while only two came with a hand-signed autograph. Both are found below, including the first card to make the list.


1999 Randy Savage Topps WCW/nWo Nitro Authentic Signatures #28 

One of the most popular Savage cards has to be his signed Topps release from 1999. It lists his name as “Macho Man” Randy Savage in orange lettering at the top, with a classic image of the wrestler on the right-hand side. 

He’s wearing the Wolfpack red and black of the nWo, which is still an over gimmick with many WWE fans.

It has a landscape design, while it makes space for a large on-card auto thanks to a lighter section on the bottom left corner.


1985 Randy Savage O-Pee-Chee WWF Series 2 #63

The 1985 O-Pee-Chee card is an RC of sorts, as Savage wasn’t included in the first officially licensed WWE trading card set produced by Topps in the same year. 

He shares the image with Miss Elizabeth, who was his real-life wife at the time. Unfortunately, Savage is looking at her rather than the camera, so his face is somewhat obscured. 

Top-Rated: Best Topps Baseball Cards Of All-Time

Copies that have earned a high grade are reasonably valuable, so this OPC card should be on your radar if you’re a big fan of Macho Man.


1994 Randy Savage Action Packed WWF #1b

The final card to make the list is the second of the signed Savage options. Only two WWE stars got an autographed card from the 1994 WWF set, with the other being the Undertaker.

Autograph cards from this set are serially numbered to 500 copies, with Savage’s appearing at the front. It uses the same image as Promo cards from the same set, and these are marked with “Prototype” on the back. Savage signed the majority of the cards “Macho Man”, although he did sign an unknown quantity of them; “Macho Man Randy Savage”.

In terms of design, it’s similar to the base card, but it’s wrapped in gold chrome, and it has the signature at the base. It’s a rare option and a must-have for fans.


Randy Poffo Baseball Card Value

Randy Poffo Baseball Card Worth

The most expensive Macho Man Randy Savage Baseball Card/Wrestling Card is the Original Art Sketch Card WWF WWE Signed Autograph 1/1 which sold on eBay for $20,000 on 1/21/2021.

Trending: Best Wayne Gretzky Rookie Cards

If you are looking to purchase a Randy Poffo baseball card but need some advice please hit us up at advice@goldcardauctions.com.


Randy Poffo Baseball Card Checklist

Randy Poffo Baseball Card Checklist

  • Macho Man Randy Savage Original Art Sketch Card WWF WWE Signed Autograph 1/1
  • 1987 Topps WWF Randy Savage & Elizabeth Sticker Rare w/HULK HOGAN On Back
  • 1994 Randy Savage Action Packed WWF #1b
  • 1985 O-Pee-Chee WWF Series 2 #63
  • 1985 OPC WWF Randy Savage Rookie Card
  • 1999 Randy Savage Topps WCW/NWO Nitro Authentic Signatures #28
  • 1987 WWF Circle K/Coke Rare
  • 1987 OPC WWF Wrestle Mania Revenge on Randy #SG
  • 1986 Monte Gum Randy Savage Macho Man #94
  • 1988 WWF Superstars Randy Macho Man Savage #KOH


Randy Poffo Baseball Cards: Buyers Guide and Investment Outlook

Investment Rating: Buy (3.4 out of 5)
Ownership Disclosure: None
Best Randy Savage Baseball Card: 1999 Randy Savage Topps WCW/NWO Nitro Authentic Signatures #28

Savage is an icon of wrestling, even if he didn’t get to fulfill his dreams of being a major league baseball star. Randy Poffo will always live on in the minds of fans, even if he might have preferred to have had a bat in hand while wowing the crowds.

“Macho Man has a couple of great signed options, which go for dizzying amounts if you’re looking at copies that have received a high grade from services such as PSA or BGS.” 

Randy Savage Wresting Cards might not be baseball cards, but they’re A DECENT investment pieces given his star power. 

One factor to consider is that wrestling is currently in a slump, and is in danger of becoming ever more obscure as the years go on. Their audience has dwindled steadily compared to the heyday of the 1980s, and later the Attitude era.

Will, there be any fans left in a couple of decades, and will that have an impact on prices for rare cards?

On the other hand, wrestling could yet enter the public consciousness once more, and Savage’s best cards would increase in price accordingly. 


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here