Kurt Warner Rookie Card – Top Cards, Value, Checklist

Kurt Warner rookie cards, much like himself pre 1999 are some of the most overlooked QB rookie cards at the position. Even though Warner was elected to the Pro Football Hall of Fame in 2017his, cards are still a STRONG BUY.


This post contains affiliate links. Read the full disclosure here.


kurt warner rookie card

Kurt Warner had one of the most unique NFL careers of any player in league history.

After going undrafted in 1994, he was signed to the Green Bay Packers practice roster before moving on to play Arena Football for 3 years.

Kurt Warner Rookie Season Stats: 16 games – 13 W – 3 L – 41 TDs – 4353 yards passing – rating 109.2 – Super Bowl MVP. Damn son that is one HELL of a rookie season.

In 1998 he returned to the NFL as a backup QB for the St. Louis Rams and shot to stardom in 1999 when, in his first full season as an NFL starter, he led the Rams to Super Bowl glory taking home both the NFL MVP and Super Bowl MVP in the same season.

Top QB Investment: Tom Brady Football Cards

He would go on to lead his teams to the playoffs on 4 more occasions, being named NFL MVP once more, and was inducted into the Pro Football Hall of Fame in 2017.

Best Kurt Warner Rookie Cards

Warner’s path to NFL stardom is so unique that his officially recognized rookie cards do not come until 1999, 5 years after he was first eligible for the draft.

There are also some interesting options available from his Arena Football days, but here we will just concentrate on his NFL cards.


1999 Kurt Warner Playoff Contenders Rookie Ticket Auto #146


1999 Kurt Warner Playoff Contenders rookie card

A staple of the rookie card list, it is no different for Warner, with him on the right in Rams uniform and the ‘Rookie Ticket’ on the left.

It features the number 13 which Warner wore throughout his career and the on-card autograph overlaps his legs.

Best Football Card Investments: Justin Herbert Rookie Cards

The cards are no serial numbered but it is confirmed that there were 1825 cards produced.

You would have to pay out big bucks just to get your hands on this base version, and there are limited run parallels if you fancy something even more top end.


1999 Kurt Warner Bowman’s Best RC #110


1999 Kurt Warner Bowman's Best rookie card

The Base Bowman’s card features Warner’s front and center as the main subject of the card, with a little detailing and blue background.

Like always with Bowman’s Best, there is an extensive list of parallels and inserts that make this a great option for every level of collector.

HOT Investment: Justin Jefferson Rookie Cards

Ranging from the cheaper common base version to the extremely expensive and rare atomic refractor and many more in between, there really is something for everyone.


1999 Kurt Warner Collector’s Edge Pro Signatures Authentics #201

1999 Kurt Warner Collector's Edge Pro Signatures

Not a card you would usually associate with high-end rookie cards, but that is a testament to just how much Warner’s career exceeded all expectations.

It features Warner in full Rams Uniform, which is overlayed by a white football in which his on-card autograph is featured.

The lack of a brand name reduces the value slightly, but you will still need to have deep pockets if you want to own a copy

There were just 500 produced, and uniquely they are all hand-numbered on the back in black ink.


Kurt Warner Rookie Card Checklist

Kurt Warner Rookie Card Checklist

  • 1999 Bowman’s Best Kurt Warner RC #110
  • 1999 Collector Edge 1st Place Kurt Warner RC #201
  • 1999 Pacific Football Kurt Warner RC AUTO #343
  • 1999 Upper Deck Encore Kurt Warner RC #KW
  • 1999 Score Football Supplemental Inscriptions Kurt Warner RC #KW13
  • 1999 Leaf R&S Touchdown Club Kurt Warner RC #TC17
  • 1999 Playoff Contenders Kurt Warner RC #146
  • 1999 Bowman’s Best Atomic Refractor Kurt Warner RC #110


Kurt Warner Rookie Card Value

Kurt Warner Rookie Card Value

The most valuable Kurt Warner rookie card is the high-end 1999 Playoff Contenders Autographs cards i.e. Speed Red (as shown above).

Trending: Best Joe Burrow Rookie Cards

If you are looking to buy a Kurt Warner rookie card and want advice please email us at advice@goldcardauctions.com or DM us on the Gold Card Auctions FB page.


Kurt Warner Rookie Card: Buyers Guide and Investment Outlook

Investment Rating: Buy (4.7 out of 5)

Best Kurt Warner Rookie Card: 1999 Playoff Contenders Rookie Ticket Autograph #146

Ownership Disclosure: None

Kurt Warner went from stock the shelves of a grocery store to Super Bowl MVP (view all Super Bowl MVPs). Talk about a zero hero story.

Not only did he win the Super Bowl but the numbers he put up in 1999 were mind-boggling… if Warner was playing in 2020 he would have tossed 100 TD passes that year… no joke.

Warner rookie cards can be had for a very reasonable price even at high grades. We love Warner rookie cards especially as long-term investments at current values.

Sports Card Investor - Trusted, sports card investor dedicated to maximizing sports card portfolio profits. Part-time contributor to Chicago Tribune.com, NBC Chicago.com, www.espn.com, wsj.com, and the Washington Times.com.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here