Top 10 Justin Verlander Rookie Cards, Value, and Outlook

SHOP JUSTIN VERLANDER ROOKIE CARDS ON EBAY

best justin verlander rookie cards

The Detroit Tigers drafted Justin Verlander (2/20/1983) with the 2nd overall pick in the first round of the 2004 MLB June Amateur Draft.

Verlander’s rookie cards were already relatively high, to begin with being the 2nd overall pick but then really took off once he won the rookie of the year in his rookie season (2006).

Justin Verlander’s rookie year stats: 186 innings pitched | 3.63 ERA | 124 strikeouts | 1.38 whip | ROY Award 1st

Best Cards

Here are 10 of the most excellent Justin Verlander cards of all time, with an eye on any that have the potential to produce a good ROI in the future.

Let’s take a trip down memory lane, starting back in 2003. 

 

#10. 2003 Justin Verlander Upper Deck USA Baseball XRC (/250) 

BUY NOW ON EBAY

2003 Justin Verlander Upper Deck USA Baseball XRC (/250)

The first card to make a list is an XRC released a couple of years before the others. 

It’s contained in a 27-card set that features the US National Baseball team, as Verlander pitched for the USA in 2003 and helped them to win a silver medal in the Pan American Games.

(The result was one of the reasons why he was the second overall pick in the 2004 MLB draft by the Detroit Tigers.)

Along with an image of the pitcher and a Team USA logo, there’s a large auto along the bottom.

 

#9. 2005 Justin Verlander Bowman Heritage RC #220 

BUY NOW ON EBAY

2005 Justin Verlander Bowman Heritage RC #220

The first Verlander RC to make a list is found in 2005 Bowman Heritage sets. 

The design is based on the 1951 Bowman collection, so there’s a simple profile shot of the player and a plain, black-and-white name tag at the bottom. A ‘Bowman Heritage First Year’ logo can be found in the top left corner. 

Compared to many others on this list, it’s an affordable entry-level Verlander RC, even when looking at gem-mint graded copies.

It’s likely to shoot up in price when he inevitably retires. 

 

#8. 2005 Justin Verlander Bowman Sterling RC #BS-JV 

BUY NOW ON EBAY

2005 Justin Verlander Bowman Sterling RC #BS-JV

On paper, the 2005 Bowman Sterling Verlander card has it all. Authentic player-worn memorabilia and a sizeable certified autograph at the bottom. 

However, it’s often disregarded in favor of more popular RC options, and that’s reflected in the overall asking price. 

It’s slightly cluttered, while the lack of a serial number is another explanation for lower values.  

The image of Verlander is tiny, and the same goes for the jersey patch. It might not be the most popular card, but it’s another decent entry-level investment piece.

 

#7. 2006 Justin Verlander Topps ’52 Signatures RC #52S-JV

BUY NOW ON EBAY

2006 Justin Verlander Topps '52 Signatures RC #52S-JV

Another RC meant to evoke memories; the 2006 Topps ‘52 collection celebrates their most prestigious set

In practice, Verlander is included in a large profile shot, looking off-camera with his glove clasped in his hands.

Investing Advice: How Much Should You Invest Annually in Sports Cards?

It has a similar name tag to the ‘52 Topps set, with one significant difference. Unlike Mickey Mantle and co, the autograph is hand-signed instead of a facsimile copy. 

The crisp golden background makes it parallel, even if it’s only a base card.  

Prices are slowly creeping up by this point, and it should be seen as a mid-level Verlander RC. 

 

#6. 2005 Justin Verlander SP Authentic RC #137

BUY NOW ON EBAY

2005 Justin Verlander SP Authentic 137

All 2005 SP Update Series cards are autographed and serial-numbered to 185 copies, and this Verlander RC is no different. 

It’s boosted by a clean blue and white design, alongside a large image of the player preparing to pitch in his Tigers uniform. 

While it might not be the rarest RC with a signature attached, it’s still pricey when looking at gem mint graded copies.

It’s another worth keeping an eye on with retirement looming.

 

#5. 2006 Justin Verlander Topps Chrome RC #309 

BUY NOW ON EBAY

2006 Justin Verlander Topps Chrome RC

Topps dominates the top five, and where better to start than Verlander’s 2006 Chrome RC?

If you take a closer look, you’ll see that it’s the same image as the one used in the 2006 Topps ’52 Signatures set, although it’s zoomed out.

This allows a clear view of the fields in the background, while it has a vintage RC logo at the bottom. 

As with any Topps Chrome Baseball card, colored refractor parallels are expensive. 

The Red Refractor offers the best balance of value and affordability, numbered 90 copies. 

2006 Justin Verlander Topps Chrome Parallels: Refractors, X-Fractor, Blue, Black (/549), Red (/90), Superfractor (1/1), Printing Plates Black (1/1), Printing Plates Cyan (1/1), Printing Plates Magenta (1/1), Printing Plates Yellow (1/1)

 

#4. 2005 Justin Verlander Topps RC #677 

BUY NOW ON EBAY

2005 Justin Verlande Topps RC #677 

This early Verlander Topps RC was released as part of a subset for “2005 First Year” players, most of whom were drafted the season before

The card features a simple profile shot of the player and a large ‘Draft Pick’ logo at the top. (You’ll also find a small chrome sentence celebrating; “54 Years of Collecting” for the company.)

Trending: Top 3 Bo Bichette Rookie Cards (and Buyer’s Guide)

It’s arguably the pick of the bunch when looking at base cards, and there are also colored parallels, including a gold version numbered to the year of release. 

2005 Justin Verlander Topps Parallels: 1st Edition (HTA only), Gold (/2005), Black (/54)

 

#3. 2006 Justin Verlander Topps RC #641

BUY NOW ON EBAY

2006 Justin Verlander Topps RC #641 

Verlander’s 2006 Topps Chrome card should be on your radar if you’d prefer a budget option. There are various colored refractors to hunt for, including a Red version limited to just 90 copies.

The lack of an auto might be slightly off-putting, but it’s still a rare, earlier release that features the player in his Tigers gear.

Don’t let the lack of an auto put you off the 2006 Topps Chrome RC if you’re looking for affordable Verlander cards. 

It might not be wrapped in chrome, but it’s a flagship Verlander rookie with graded versions that sell for a fraction of the price compared to the cards seen above and below.

The card also shares the same image as the Topps Chrome release from the same year.)

2006 Justin Verlander Topps Chrome Parallels: Refractor – X-Fractor – Blue Refractor  – Black Refractor Serial #/549 – Red Refractor Serial #/90 – Superfractor Serial #1/1 – Printing Plates #1/1

 

#2. 2005 Justin Verlander Topps Chrome RC #242

BUY NOW ON EBAY

2005 Justin Verlander Topps Chrome rookie card

Let’s list the facts.

This is a 2005 Verlander RC, with auto on the bottom, boosted by the power of the Topps brand, and it’s wrapped in a sleek chrome finish. 

It’s a wonder this card didn’t take the top spot, and it’s a great contender for potential ROI in the future. 

Parallel versions aren’t as plentiful as they would be with a current release, so there are numbered black, red, and gold refractors and base versions limited to 500 copies.  

Verlander’s 2005 Topps Chrome RC is undoubtedly one of the more popular options, especially when looking at Refractor parallels that are serial-numbered to 500 and below.

Unlike many other rookie cards, the player is the main focus, with a smiling profile photo-taking center stage. His surname is found in block capitals at the top, while there’s an excellent auto found at the bottom.

Given the chrome finish and advancing years, finding new, graded versions is difficult.

2005 Justin Verlander Topps Chrome Parallels: Refractors (/500), Black Refractors (/200), Red X-fractors (/25), Gold Superfractors (1/1), Printing Plates Black (1/1), Printing Plates Cyan (1/1), Printing Plates Magenta (1/1), Printing Plates Yellow (1/1)

 

#1A. 2005 Justin Verlander Bowman Chrome RC #331 

BUY NOW ON EBAY

2005 Justin Verlander Bowman Chrome Rookie Card

Rather than Topps, Verlander’s 2005 Bowman Chrome RC takes the number one spot on this list. 

Bowman Chrome autos tend to be preferred by collectors interested in modern rookie and prospect cards.

The base card is reasonably valuable if it’s a graded gem mint copy, but the real money is found within numbered refractor parallels.

There’s also a signature found at the bottom, and chrome parallels are numerous. We prefer the Topps card, but either could be a great investment piece in the long term.

2005 Justin Verlander Bowman Chrome Parallels: Refractors (/500), X-fractors (/225), Blue Refractors (/150), Gold Refractors (/50), Red Refractors (/5), Printing Plates Black (1/1), Printing Plates Cyan (1/1), Printing Plates Magenta (1/1), Printing Plates Yellow (1/1), Superfractors (1/1)

 

#1. 2005 Justin Verlander Upper Deck Update Autograph RC /75 #180

BUY NOW ON EBAY

2005 Justin Verlander Upper Deck Update Auto

Good luck getting your hands on this baby. We could barely find a photo, less obtain the actual card for our portfolio.

Email owner@goldcardauctions.com if you have this card graded or have a lead on this card. Thank you.

 

Checklist

Justin Verlander Rookie Card Checklist

  • 2005 Upper Deck Sweet Spot Justin Verlander RC #59
  • 2005 Topps Chrome Auto Justin Verlander RC #242
  • 2005 Bowman Draft Picks Justin Verlander RC #BDP129
  • 2005 Donruss Champions Holo Justin Verlander RC #381
  • 2005 Upper Deck Reflections Justin Verlander RC #241
  • 2005 Upper Deck Star Rookie Justin Verlander RC #430
  • 2005 Topps Black #1 Pick Justin Verlander RC #1
  • 2005 Diamond Kings Justin Verlander RC #265
  • 2005 Bowman Heritage Justin Verlander RC #220
  • 2005 Donruss Team Heroes Justin Verlander RC #371
  • 2005 Throwback Threads Justin Verlander RC #213
  • 2005 Artifacts Justin Verlander RC #237 /799
  • 2005 Bowman Justin Verlander RC #174
  • 2005 Origins Justin Verlander RC #241
  • 2005 Origins Old Judge Justin Verlander RC #241
  • 2005 Flair Justin Verlander RC #68 /699
  • 2005 Playoff Prestige Justin Verlander RC #151
  • 2005 Absolute Memorabilia Justin Verlander RC #100
  • 2005 Fleer Patchworks Justin Verlander /499 RC #75
  • 2005 SkyBox Autographics Justin Verlander /750 RC #115
  • 2005 Classic Clippings Justin Verlander RC #125
  • 2005 Fleer Platinum Justin Verlander RC /1000 #105
  • 2005 Leafs Certified Materials Blue Mirror Justin Verlander RC
  • 2005 Topps Update Justin Verlander RC #UH220
  • 2005 Leaf Certified Materials Justin Verlander RC Autograph /299 #221
  • 2005 Donruss Signature Justin Verlander RC Autograph with Jeff Niemann, Phil Humber #157
  • 2005 National Pastime Justin Verlander RC /699 #69
  • 2005 Donruss Classics Justin Verlander RC Autograph /400 #201
  • 2005 Topps Pristine Justin Verlander RC #101
  • 2005 UD Portraits Justin Verlander RC #84
  • 2005 Zenith Justin Verlander RC #213
  • 2005 Studio Justin Verlander RC #114
  • 2005 Donruss Elite Justin Verlander RC Autograph /500 #176
  • 2005 Topps Justin Verlander RC #677
  • 2005 Timeless Treasures Justin Verlander RC #59 /799
  • 2006 Topps Turkey Justin Verlander RC #272
  • 2006 Topps 52 Dynamic Duos DD3 Joel Zumaya/Justin Verlander RC
  • 2006 Topps Chrome Justin Verlander RC #641

 

Justin Verlander Rookie Card Value

Justin Verlander Rookie Card Value

The most expensive Justin Verlander rookie card is the 2005 Topps Chrome Black Refractor RC /200 #242, selling for $1,425 via eBay auctions on 3/1/2021.

Have some old Justin Verlander baseball cards and want to know what they might be worth. Email value@goldcardauctions.com for more information.

Trending: 1990’s Most Expensive Hockey Cards

If you’re looking to purchase a Justin Verlander RC and need advice, please call us at advice@goldcardauctions.com or comment at the end of the write-up.

 

Rating and Investment Outlook

Verlander is considered a lock for the Hall of Fame if and when he decides to retire sometime over the next decade. The pitcher has won it over the years and added a second Cy Young award in 2019  to his impressive legacy.

Investment Rating: Buy (4.0 out of 5)
Ownership Disclosure: None
Best Justin Verlander Rookie Card: 2005 Topps Chrome Auto RC #242

His cards are relatively underpriced and should see decent improvement when he calls time on his career. The same is true when he joins the Hall of Fame, so we’d recommend keeping tabs on prices in the meantime.

He missed the 2020 season following injury, which is another reason his cards are cheaper than they could be. Verlander will be back in the mix soon enough, and it’ll serve as another reminder for investors and collectors.

Leave a Comment