Verlander’s rookie cards were already relatively high, to begin with being the 2nd overall pick but then really took off once he won the rookie of the year in his rookie season (2006).
Related: Best Miguel Cabera Rookie Cards
Justin Verlander rookie year stats: 186 innings pitched | 3.63 ERA | 124 strikeouts | 1.38 whip | ROY Award 1st
Best Justin Verlander Rookie Cards
Let’s take a look at the top-rated Justin Verlander rookie cards from an investment perspective, which will have the best ROI moving forward.
2005 Justin Verlander Topps Chrome Auto RC #242
Verlander’s 2005 Topps Chrome RC is undoubtedly one of the more popular options, especially when looking at Refractor parallels that are serial-numbered to 500 and below.
Unlike many other rookie cards, the player is the main focus here, with a smiling profile photo-taking center stage. His surname is found in block capitals at the top, while there’s a great auto found at the bottom.
Given the chrome finish and its advancing years, it’s difficult to find pristine, graded versions.
2005 Justin Verlander Topps Chrome Parallels: Refractors #/500, Black Refractors #/200, Red X-fractors #/25, Gold Superfractors 1/1, Printing Plates Black 1/1, Printing Plates Cyan 1/1, Printing Plates Magenta 1/1, Printing Plates Yellow 1/1
2005 Justin Verlander Bowman Chrome Autograph RC #331
Coming in a close second, his 2005 Bowman Chrome RC is similar to the Topps card in many respects. It features a posed photo of Verlander, with his hands clasped together.
Trending: Best Roger Clemens Rookie Cards
There’s also a signature found at the bottom, and chrome parallels are numerous. We personally prefer the Topps card, but either could be a great investment piece in the long term.
2005 Justin Verlander Bowman Chrome Parallels: Refractors (/500), X-fractors (/225), Blue Refractors (/150), Gold Refractors (/50), Red Refractors (/5), Printing Plates Black (1/1), Printing Plates Cyan (1/1), Printing Plates Magenta (1/1), Printing Plates Yellow (1/1), Superfractors (1/1)
2006 Justin Verlander Topps Chrome RC #641
If you’d prefer a budget option, Verlander’s 2006 Topps Chrome card should be on your radar. There’s a variety of colored refractors to hunt for, including a Red version limited to just 90 copies.
The lack of an auto might be slightly off-putting, but it’s still a rare, earlier release that features the player in his Tigers gear.
2006 Justin Verlander Topps Chrome Parallels: Refractor – X-Fractor – Blue Refractor – Black Refractor Serial #/549 – Red Refractor Serial #/90 – Superfractor Serial #1/1 – Printing Plates #1/1
Justin Verlander Rookie Card Checklist
- 2005 Upper Deck Sweet Spot Justin Verlander RC #59
- 2005 Topps Chrome Auto Justin Verlander RC #242
- 2005 Bowman Draft Picks Justin Verlander RC #BDP129
- 2005 Donruss Champions Holo Justin Verlander RC #381
- 2005 Upper Deck Reflections Justin Verlander RC #241
- 2005 Upper Deck Star Rookie Justin Verlander RC #430
- 2005 Topps Black #1 Pick Justin Verlander RC #1
- 2005 Diamond Kings Justin Verlander RC #265
- 2005 Bowman Heritage Justin Verlander RC #220
- 2005 Donruss Team Heroes Justin Verlander RC #371
- 2005 Throwback Threads Justin Verlander RC #213
- 2005 Artifacts Justin Verlander RC #237 /799
- 2005 Bowman Justin Verlander RC #174
- 2005 Origins Justin Verlander RC #241
- 2005 Origins Old Judge Justin Verlander RC #241
- 2005 Flair Justin Verlander RC #68 /699
- 2005 Playoff Prestige Justin Verlander RC #151
- 2005 Absolute Memorabilia Justin Verlander RC #100
- 2005 Fleer Patchworks Justin Verlander /499 RC #75
- 2005 SkyBox Autographics Justin Verlander /750 RC #115
- 2005 Classic Clippings Justin Verlander RC #125
- 2005 Fleer Platinum Justin Verlander RC /1000 #105
- 2005 Leafs Certified Materials Blue Mirror Justin Verlander RC
- 2005 Topps Update Justin Verlander RC #UH220
- 2005 Leaf Certified Materials Justin Verlander RC Autograph /299 #221
- 2005 Donruss Signature Justin Verlander RC Autograph with Jeff Niemann, Phil Humber #157
- 2005 National Pastime Justin Verlander RC /699 #69
- 2005 Donruss Classics Justin Verlander RC Autograph /400 #201
- 2005 Topps Pristine Justin Verlander RC #101
- 2005 UD Portraits Justin Verlander RC #84
- 2005 Zenith Justin Verlander RC #213
- 2005 Studio Justin Verlander RC #114
- 2005 Donruss Elite Justin Verlander RC Autograph /500 #176
- 2005 Topps Justin Verlander RC #677
- 2005 Timeless Treasures Justin Verlander RC #59 /799
- 2006 Topps Turkey Justin Verlander RC #272
- 2006 Topps 52 Dynamic Duos DD3 Joel Zumaya/Justin Verlander RC
- 2006 Topps Chrome Justin Verlander RC #641
Justin Verlander Rookie Card Value
The most expensive Justin Verlander rookie card is the 2005 Topps Chrome Black Refractor RC /200 #242, selling for $1,425 via eBay auctions on 3/1/2021.
Have some old Justin Verlander baseball cards and would like to know what they might be worth? Email firstname.lastname@example.org for more information.
Trending: 1990’s Most Expensive Hockey Cards
If you’re looking to purchase a Justin Verlander RC and need advice, please hit us up at email@example.com or comment at the end of the write-up.
Justin Verlander Rookie Card: Buyer Rating and Investment Outlook
Verlander is considered to be a lock for the Hall of Fame, if and when he decides to retire sometime over the next decade. The pitcher has won it all over the years and added a second Cy Young award in 2019 to his impressive legacy.
Investment Rating: Buy (4.0 out of 5)
Ownership Disclosure: None
Best Justin Verlander Rookie Card: 2005 Topps Chrome Auto RC #242
His cards are relatively underpriced and should see decent improvement when he calls time on his career. The same is true when he joins the Hall of Fame, so we’d recommend keeping tabs on prices in the meantime.
He missed the 2020 season following injury, which is another reason why his cards are cheaper than they could be. Verlander will be back in the mix soon enough, and it’ll serve as another reminder for investors and collectors.