This post contains affiliate links to include the eBay Partner Network which may earn a commission. We truly appreciate your support.

Best Justin Fields Rookie Cards

Justin Fields took a winding path to the NFL. He went from baseball prospect to backup quarterback at UGA, to Ohio State starter, and finally to NFL draft pick.


Winding path aside, few doubted Fields would eventually become a first-round pick, assuming he chose football over baseball.

His talent and leadership qualities made him among the top college football recruits. They also led him to success in his two seasons at Ohio State. Now, they have NFL execs tantalized.

Gutting it out through an injury while topping Trevor Lawrence and Clemson in the 2021 Sugar Bowl only cemented Fields as a future top pick.

We cannot be sure what Fields’ NFL future holds. As a card investor, this should excite you. Uncertainty allows you to secure a Fields rookie card on the cheap.

The cards listed here are college and prospect cards, not official NFL rookie cards. As Fields settles into his NFL home, check back for those official rookie cards to be released.


2021 Justin Fields Leaf Pro Set Auto RC #PSA2

Buy on eBay

Pro Set took a long hiatus from the football card trade, as its most recent set before this year was printed in 1993. What’s the saying? Good things are worth the wait?

Pro Set picked a strong rookie class to feature in its re-debut. Along with this Justin Fields college card, the Pro Set batch also features fellow rookies-to-be Trevor Lawrence and Zach Wilson.

Must Buy: Justin Herbert Rookie Cards

Since we are featuring Fields here, let’s examine his 2021 Leaf Pro Set Auto #PSA2 a bit closer.

Fields’ unique signature is featured in blue ink on a pristine white background as an autograph card. Fields grasp the football with two hands in his white Ohio State Buckeyes uniform.

The card was designed with a retro feel in mind. In fact, it’s the exact same design from the 1993 set of Pro Set rookie cards.

A primary orange border contains white boxes along the sides. Fields’ purple and gold nameplate is located above his image, positioned in between the Pro Set logo and a nondescript football helmet.

The autograph makes this card worth owning, though a mint version may cost you in the high three figures or low four-figure range…for now.

You can also secure a non-autographed version of this card. It will cost you significantly less, likely less than three figures.

As one of the earliest Justin Fields football cards from a legitimate manufacturer, it might be worth taking a flier that even the non-autographed card will appreciate.


2017 Justin Fields Leaf Perfect Game Nike Auto RC #288

Buy on eBay

When you think of Justin Fields, you probably don’t think of baseball. As a card investor, you might want to change your thinking a bit.

Though he’s known today as a quarterback, Fields was once a highly-touted baseball prospect as well as stud high school quarterback. Like Russell Wilson and Tim Tebow, Fields chose football.

Valuable prospect and rookie cards featuring Fields (in any sport) are few and far between. Accordingly, this Fields baseball card has strong value.

As Fields football cards are printed in greater quantities, Fields baseball cards will appear increasingly scarce by comparison.

The 2017 Leaf Perfect Game card shows Fields having just released a baseball. He’s in a uniform provided for his prospect showcase, with a red jersey, grey pants, and black hat with a white “PG” (Perfect Game) logo.

The card’s tone is white. Fields’ image is surrounded by a white background with a slight green tint just behind him. The Leaf scrawl is in the upper-righthand corner, but it is one of the few design features on this card.

Fun Read: When Baseball Cards Worth Millions Were Found in Homes

An appealing feature of this card is the autograph. Under a PG logo and a Nike swoosh is Fields’ signature in blue ink. It’s a different signature than other Fields cards, indicating that he has yet to decide on a signature…well, signature.

As Fields forges his NFL career, a signed card featuring him playing an entirely different sport will likely gain greater novelty. This novelty can translate to a return on investment.



  • 2021 Pro Set Autograph Auto /99 Justin Fields RC #PSA2
  • 2017 Leaf Perfect Game Nike Auto Justin Fields RC #288
  • 2017 Leaf Perfect Game Nike Justin Fields RC #288
  • 2020 SI Kids Sports Illustrated for Kids Justin Fields RC #943
  • 2017 Leaf Perfect Game Black /50 Rookie Autograph Justin Fields RC



The most expensive Justin Fields rookie card released to date is the 2021 Justin Fields Leaf Pro Set Auto rookie card #PSA2.

Contact Gold Card Auctions
Estimated Sports Card Value:
Sports Card Buying Advice:
Rookie Card Review Request:

Please check back every couple of weeks as his rookie cards will improve over the next 12 months as he is welcomed to the NFL via the NFL Draft on 4/29/2021.


Investment Outlook

Justin Fields COULD be the franchise quarterback, not a franchise shortstop or second baseman (his listed positions as a high school baseball star).

  • Investment Rating: Pass (2.2 out of 5)
  • Ownership Disclosure: None
  • Best Justin Fields Rookie Card: 2017 Justin Fields Leaf Perfect Game Nike Auto RC #288

Nonetheless, we’ve included two baseball prospect cards in this list because:

  • The cards are valued highly as investments
  • Valuable Fields football cards are virtually nonexistent

If you’re a Fields fan or a fan of making money on your trading card investment, does the sport matter anyway?

Bottom Line: Justin Fields will play football in the NFL, but we’re just not convinced he will be any better than other Ohio St QB’s the NFL has chewed up and spit out.

Categorized in: