Jonathan Taylor Rookie Card – Top 3 Cards, Worth, and Risk/Profit Analysis

This page contains affiliate links, meaning we get a commission if you decide to make a purchase through our links, at no cost to you.

Buy Jonathan Taylor Rookie Cards on eBay

Jonathan Taylor rookie card

Jonathan Taylor (01/19/99) is an RB who was drafted by the Indianapolis Colts (41st overall) in 2020. The hottest of prospects, he’s a two-time recipient of the Doak Walker Award, honoring the top running back in  United States college football.

Collectors and investors have already begun to take notice of Taylor’s shiny RC options, so here’s a rundown with three of his best early cards, including an investment outlook for his rookie year and the next couple of seasons.

Best Jonathan Taylor Rookie Cards 

We’ve combed through recent auction data to bring you a list with three of the best Jonathan Taylor rookie cards that are available right now. Panini dominates as usual, but there’s a good range of options overall.


2020 Jonathan Taylor Panini Prizm RC #332

Buy on eBay

Jonathan Taylor prizm rookie card

Jonathan Taylor Prizm’s rookie cards are not only the most popular of his cards but will also generate a good to very good ROI if his career flourishes.

Available in a variety of parrlels. The higher the parrel you can afford the higher the ROI should be.


2020 Jonathan Taylor Mosaic RC #216

jonathan taylor mosaic rookie card

We are HUGE fans of the 2020 Mosaic football cards and would love if they continue printing them for years and years to come. In regards to 2020 Prizm football cards vs 2020 Mosaic football cards, we actually prefer the Mosaic as we love the modern-looking designs and how well the cards have held up to PSA grading.

Having said that it should be obvious that the 2020 Mosaic Jonathan Taylor rookie card is our top pick.

Below is an example of why we love the 2020 Mosaic set in terms of design. A gorgeous Mosaic Reactive Orange Jonathan Taylor rookie card PSA 10 grade. The only question is can they follow up in 2021 with a great part 2 (unlike they did with the 2019 Panini Opulence brand in basketball).

jonathan taylor mosaic rookie cards

Buy 2020 Jonathan Taylor Autograph Rookie Cards on eBay


2020 Jonathan Taylor National Treasures RPA /99 RC 

Buy on eBay

2020 National Treasures JONATHAN TAYLOR True Rookie Patch Auto

If you have the wallet combined with the faith that Taylor is going to have a huge career in please consider the NFL the National Treasures /99 RPA Taylor rookie card.


Jonathan Taylor Rookie Card Checklist

Jonathan Taylor Rookie Card Checklist

  • 2020 Contenders Draft Picks Autograph /25 Jonathan Taylor RC #110
  • 2020 Obsidian Draft Picks /49 Jonathan Taylor RC
  • 2020 Mosaic Jonathan Taylor RC #216
  • 2020 Mosaic Jonathan Taylor RC #RA16
  • 2020 Panini Luminance Auto Gold Jonathan Taylor RC /100
  • 2020 Chronicles Draft Picks Crown Royale Jonathan Taylor RC #37
  • 2020 Panini Prizm Jonathan Taylor RC #106
  • 2020 Panini College Ticket Jonathan Taylor RC
  • 2020 Chronicles Draft Picks Prizm Patch Auto Jonathan Taylor RC #6
  • 2020 Panini Luminance Rookie Luminance Autograph Blue Jonathan Taylor RC #114
  • 2020 Panini Legacy Silver Premium Edition Jonathan Taylor RC #157
  • 2020 Leaf Flash Auto Jonathan Taylor RC
  • 2020 Jonathan Taylor National Treasures RPA /99 RC #
  • 2020 Legacy Rookies Jonathan Taylor RC #157


Jonathan Taylor Rookie Card Value

The most valuable Jonathan Taylor rookie card is the 2020 National Treasures RPA /99 rookie card.

If you are on the brink of buying a Jonathan Taylor rookie card but would like a second opinion please email us at and we will provide input.


Jonathan Taylor Rookie Card: Buyers Guide & Risk/Return Analysis

Taylor ended his college career at fourth on the all-time FBS rushing-yards list with 6,174 yards, despite leaving a year earlier to join the draft and the Colts.

Investment Rating: Pass (2.7 out of 5)

Risk/Profit Analysis: Moderate to High Risk/Low to High Return

Best Jonathan Taylor Rookie Card: 2020 Mosaic Jonathan Taylor RC #216

Ownership Disclosure: None

They traded up for the chance to add Taylor to their roster, so he’s clearly a major part of their long-term plans for the time being.

He’ll be up against NFL vet Marlon Mack who has started 22 of 40 career games with the Colts, but head coach Frank Reich has promised that both RBs will get good game time over the season.

Of course, it’s still unclear as to who will be the undisputed starter when all is said and done.

From an investment perspective, his cards are reasonably affordable, and he has a good chance of highlighting why his team took the opportunity to trade up for his services.

There are lots of interesting parallels that have such low numbers to choose from, and it’s not like you’ll stand to make a major loss if he spends the season on the sidelines.

Having said that we just can’t wrap our heads around spending any of our portfolio coins on Taylor rookie cards… for now… check back later in 2021 and we may sing a different tune.

Maximize Your Sports Card Profits: View our HOTTEST Hobby Boxes to Buy in May of 2022 for BIG PULLS!
Sports Card Investor - Trusted, sports card investor dedicated to maximizing sports card portfolio profits. Part-time contributor to Chicago, NBC,,, and the Washington


  1. It’s been almost a year since you wrote this article and I think it’s due for an update since Taylor has put in another great season. I really think his “Invest Rating of 2.7 out of 5” should be increased because of his 2021 season. I also think the “Best Jonathan Taylor Rookie Cards” needs updating. The 2021 Panini Phoenix Fire Burst should make the list.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here