Joe Montana Rookie Card – Top 3 Cards, Checklis, Top Value

Not only are Joe Montana rookie cards a great long-term investment in terms of ROI but they are also one of the safest buys in the entire hobby. Suggested in grades PSA 10 to 4 or SGC 10 to 6.

This page contains affiliate links, meaning we get a commission if you decide to make a purchase through our links, at no cost to you.


joe montana rookie cards

Joe Montana (6/11/1956) was born in New Eagle, PA, and was drafted by the San Fransico 49ers in the 3rd round of the 1979 NFL Draft (72 overall).

He played 15 years in the NFL, 13 years of which was with the San Fransico 49ers and 2 years with the Kansas City Chiefs.

Joe Montana played in 23 playoff games, had 26 comebacks, and a mind-blowing 28 game-winning drive.

Joe Montana Rookie Year Stats:  7 games started | 1795 yards passing | 15 touchdown passes | 87.8 rating

  • Full Name: Joseph Clifford Montana Jr.
  • Position: QB
  • Throws: Right
  • Vitals: 6-2, 200lb

Trending: Best Sports Cards To Buy Now

Best Joe Montana Rookie Cards

There is really only one Joe Montana rookie card worth owning.

We listed two other Joe Montana football cards that should make for a good long-term investment and rival his rookie card in terms of ROI.


1981 Joe Montana Topps Rookie Card #216

Check Price

Joe Montana Topps Rookie Card

This is the only true Joe Montana rookie card. It was produced by Topps in 1981 and shows Joe tossing the football in his home 49ers jersey.

If you own the 1981 Joe Montana Topps Rookie Card in a PSA 10 grade please DM us on Facebook or email us at

Since this is pretty much the only Montana rookie card you should pretty much always be able to find at least one for sale on eBay.

Must Read: Rookie Cards That Could Double in 2021


1985 Joe Montana Topps Football Card #157

oe Montana Topps Football Card

For whatever reason, there is not many early Joe Montana card to pick from (most likely due to the lack of popularity in football cards at the time). The 1985 Montana Topps card came up in our search and a PSA 10 card sold for $421 in early 2020.

Top-Rated Investment: Troy Aikman Rookie Cards

The card pictures Joe warming up and has a pretty cool-looking black border. We might actually like the looks of this card better than his rookie card.


1983 Topps Joe Montana 49ers Football Card #169

1983 Topps Joe Montana

Here is another non-rookie Joe Montana card worth owning and is ideal for investors looking for a nice steady gainer year over year.

Trending: Best Terry Bradshaw Rookie Cards

You should be able to find this card in good condition (PSA 10) for under $50.


Most Valuable Joe Montana Card

The most valuable Joe Montana card is his 1981 Topps Joe Montana RC #216 as a PSA 10 grade sold on eBay for $60,000 on 5/24/2021.


Joe Montana Rookie Card Checklist

  • 1981 Topps Joe Montana RC #216
  • 1981 Topps Rookie Progressive Blue Proof Joe Montana RC #216


Joe Montana Rookie Card Value

Joe Montana Rookie Card Value

Most Common on eBay Auctions: 1981 Topps RC #216

The most expensive Joe Montana rookie card is the 1981 Topps #216 at a PSA 10 grade. If one graded BGS 10 Black Label ever appears that would top the PSA in terms of value.

As we previously mentioned the value of Joe Montana rookie cards should have a steady upward ROI for the foreseeable future with little risk other than what comes with the industry as a whole.

Trending: Best Justin Herbert Rookie Cards

If you would like an estimated value on a Joe Montana football card please email us a minimum of two pics to

Looking to purchase a Joe Montana but would like to avoid the dreaded buyer’s remorse? Email us at and we can assist.

You can also check us out on Facebook at


Joe Montana Rookie Card: Risk/Return Analysis and Investment Outlook

Before Tom Brady starting winning Superbowls, Joe Montana was considered the best QB ever to play the game, and some still think him the same.

But most close to the game have acknowledged that Montana is no longer the top QB of all-time, but that doesn’t mean his rookie cards aren’t excellent investments.

Investment Rating: Buy (4.5 out of 5)

Risk/Return Analysis: Low Risk/Moderately High to High Return

Ownership Disclosure: None

Best Rookie Card: 1981 Topps Rookie Card #216

His rookie cards remain a great investment option and one of the more secure as they should provide steady gains year over year.

Trending: Top 10 Wander Franco Rookie Cards

Don’t expect massive returns but you can sleep easy knowing there is very little risk here and a nice size return of investment year after year.

Maximize Your Sports Card Profits: View our HOTTEST Hobby Boxes to Buy in May of 2022 for BIG PULLS!


  1. I have 4 Joe Montana rookie cards yet to be graded. They are in mint condition to look at. Also I have Larry Bird rookie card and Julius Erving, Magic Johnson, and Kareem Abdual Jabbar. And many more from early 70s to early 80s.

    • Listen if you want to make some money I need you to text me or call me as soon as possible 321-917-3177 my name is Kenny you will not regret this. I want to start off by saying I do not know anything about card to tell me what I’ve learned in the past few days. I’ll throw a few examples out there I do have the Joe Montana error card number two and I do know that is pretty sizable after it’s graded but I’m only that I actually have three of those. I do have a Peyton Manning card with his jersey on it there’s only four hundred something of those made I have Wayne Gretzky rookie cards Emmitt Smith rookie card listen I have are cards boxes don’t listen all I know is I have a lot a lot a lot of value and I am broke I don’t even have enough money to rub two pennies together I would take an offer that you would not believe it’s up to you if you want to text me if you’re about to hit the jackpot because I’m broke as hell and I’m sitting on a gold mine

      • Montana aas my hero since i was about 9 yeara old i know that i own over 400 different montana cards not only that i have emmit and irvins rookie cards along with a ton of early football and basketball rookies shaq barry sanders id lobe to get a value on some

  2. I have a perfect Topps #216 Joe Montana RC but the borders are not even where it was cut. I was wondering if that affects the value or not and would very much appreciate your opinion. I also
    have a mint Topps #161Jerry Rice RC in mint condition and was wondering how I can have them graded

  3. I have a Joe Montana Carol ringgold high School committed to Notre Dame basketball card I believe it’s from future stock it’s in mint condition it’s in the plastic it came in I’d have to send you a pic I want to know what it’s worth I can’t find it anywhere online can somebody help me please

  4. I have a Joe Montana’s Rookie card. 216. Mint condition. Wanting to sell. Also I have John Elway rookie mint condition! Number 63. Wanted to sell


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here