Gardner Minshew Rookie Card – 3 Best Cards and Recommended Buys


This post contains affiliate links. Read the full disclosure here.

Gardner Minshew rookie cards are a hot ticket item as many in the hobby expect big things from the kid in just his second season with the Jaguars.

Which Minshew rookie cards should you be buying if your in this camp? Keep reading to find out!

Gardner Minshew Rookie Card

Shop for Gardner Minshew Rookie Card on eBay

Gardner Minshew II was drafted by the Jacksonville Jaguars in the 6th round (178th overall pick) of the 2019 NFL Draft.

The kid was a long shot but came out guns a-blazing in his rookie season passing for 3,271 yards to go along with 21 touchdown passes and a 91.2 QBR… not bad… not bad at all for a rookie.

As you can imagine Gardner Minshew rookie card values took of as collectors were intrigued by the 6th rd pick with the bushy mustache.

His first-year performance was enough to earn him the starting gig heading into the 2020 season and some are calling for a break out ayear while others are predicting an utter collapse.

If you are in the first school of thought here are the Minshew rookie cards you will want to invest your hard earn cash in.

Top Gardner Minshew Rookie Cards


2019 Gardner Minshew II Panini Prizm Rookie Card #322 (buy on eBay)

Gardner Minshew Rookie Card Prizm

The Minshew Prizm rookie card may be your best bang for your buck.

Numbered #322 the card shows Minshew in his practice jersey while in mid-throw.

This Prizm card is our bet for delivering the best return on investment (ROI) should Minshew blast off to stardom.

2019 Prizm Parallels: Prizms – Blue Prizms – Disco Prizms – Green Prizms – Red Ice Prizms – Lazer Prizms – Neon Green Prizms – Pink Prizms – Red Prizms – Red, White and Blue Prizms – White Sparkle Prizms – Orange Prizms /249 – Blue Wave Prizms /199 – Hyper Prizms /175 – Red Wave Prizms /149 – Blue Ice Prizms /99 – Green Scope Prizms /75 – Purple Power Prizms /49 – Camo Prizms /25 – Red Shimmer Prizms /15 – Blue Shimmer Prizms /10 – Gold Prizms /10 – Gold Vinyl Prizms /5 – Green Shimmer Prizms /2 – Black Finite Prizms  1/1

One of the best investments in the hobby? Tom Brady Rookie Cards


2019 Gardner Minshew II National Treasures Rookie Jersey Patch Auto #198 (buy on eBay)

Panini National Treasures Gardner Minshew Rookie Patch Auto )

This should be the most expensive Gardner Minshew rookie card regardless of what he does over the next few years.

Numbered #198 this National Treasures card shows Gardner chucking the pigskin downfield for what is hopefully a completed pass.

This bad boy also includes a game-used patch and an autograph! WOOT WOOT!!

Rookie of the year? Cee Dee Lamb rookie cards are a good buy


2019 Gardner Minshew ll Contenders Autograph Championship/Rookie Ticket #186 (buy on eBay)

GARDNER MINSHEW II 2019 Contenders Autograph Auto Rookie card

The Minshew Panini Contenders rookie card barely squeaks out a win over the Panini Flawless (both are super nice cards and it could go either way really).

Numbered #186 the card shows Minshsew dropping back in the pocket, scanning the field for an open wideout or tight end.

A nice card for the moderate bankroll.


Gardner Minshew Rookie Card Value

Minshew rookie card values are fairly affordable unless you’re talking about super high-end National Treasures which will cost into the low thousands… but otherwise, a few hundred is reasonable.

BUT this is 100% subject to change heading into 2020 and could go either way.

Gardner Minshew rookie card worth estimate? As always email us with 2 photos at a minimum and we will try to get back with you in 72 hours or less (also hit us on the Gold Card Auctions Facebook Page).


Gardner Minshew II Rookie Card Checklist

Gardner Minshew Rookie Card Checklist

  • 2019 Panini Flawless
  • 2019 Panini Select
  • 2019 Panini Black Friday Prizm Refractor
  • 2019 Donruss Optic #142
  • 2019 Panini Prizm #322
  • 2019 National Treasures FOTL #198
  • 2019 Contenders Autograph Rookie Ticket #186
  • 2019 Contenders Autograph Championship Ticket #186
  • 2019 Legacy #166
  • 2019 Panini Playbook Blue /49 Auto Rookie Card
  • 2019 Panini Contenders Rookie of the Year Contenders #26
  • 2019 Panini Contenders Draft Picks Auto
  • 2019 Panini Score #366
  • 2019 Select Prizm Die-Cut RC
  • 2019 Panini One Gardner Minshew II Autograph Rookie /99

A good read: Most Valuable Football Cards from the 1990s


Best Gardner Minshew Rookie Card (Recommended Buy)

As we alluded to earlier in the article we feel the 2019 Gardner Minshew II Prizm rookie card is going to be your best buy when it comes to ROI.

This is ideal for moderate bankrolls as the card will cost under $100… cheers!


Investment Outlook

gardner minshew auto

Flip a coin… that’s how we feel about Minshew as a breakout QB next year… we aren’t saying hell no as we did Baker Mayfield last year but we aren’t saying hell yes like we are Drew Lock this year.

The kid obviously has some talent based on some of his games in 2019, he just needs to put it all together which may be easier said than done in Jacksonville where QB having been dying like honey bees lately.

If we were forced to put a million dollars one way or another we would lean slightly towards breakout over bust 52% to 48%.

Investment Rating: Weak Buy


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here