We love a baseball error card. Not only are they out of the ordinary from the standard card but in some cases more valuable.
Top Error Baseball Cards
A great error card combines an unusual feature (a bad word on the butt of the bat) with extreme rarity (the less of the error cards produced the more valuable it will be).
Here are some of the best baseball error cards from an investment viewpoint. If you have any error cards you like please share them in the comment section.
Below are our personal favorites when it comes to baseball error cards. FYI we snuck a basketball error card in, we simply had to include it due to a variety of reasons. Enjoy.
#1. 1990 Frank Thomas No Name Topps Error Card #414
One of the most popular and most expensive of all error cards.
#2. 1989 Bill Ripken F Face Error Card #616
Our personal favorite.
#3. 1992 Michael Jordan Upper Deck Error Card Champ ’85 and ’95
Although not a baseball error card we included this error card as it should have the best long-term ROI (and that is why it’s included).
#4. 1969 Mickey Mantle Topps Mantle in White Letters Error Card
One of the more expensive of all the error cards and you can’t go wrong owning a Mickey Mantle baseball card in terms of ROI.
#5. 1987 Barry Bonds Donruss Opening Day Error Card
Wait! That is not Barry Bonds in the photo! It is Johnny Ray?! Who in the hell is that?
#6. 1990 Ken Griffey Jr. Donruss No Dot After Inc Error Card #365
There are also rumors of a second error associated with this card but we could not confirm them. Something in regards to an eye.
#7. 1989 Gary Sheffield Upper Deck SS Upside Down Error Card #13
We feel this one is the most undervalued and overlooked baseball error card of all time. A great long-term investment from a historical set (the same set that holds one of the most popular cards in the hobby in the 1989 Ken Griffey Jr. Upper Deck Rookie Card #1).
#8. 1989 Dale Murphy Upper Deck Reverse Negative Error Card #357
Another from the 1989 Upper Deck baseball set. Were they drunk when printing this bad boy?
#9. 1909 – 1911 Sherry “Magie” Misspelling Piedmont T206 Error Card
Old school T206 error card. Super valuable and super rare.
#10. 1952 Joe Page Sain Bio Topps Black Back Error Card #48
Another old one. We don’t care much for this one but apparently, others in the hobby do as it appears often in baseball error card discussion.
UPDATE: We are adding two more to make it 12 in total!
WOW! Talk about one of the craziest errors in all of the baseball cards.
The 2000 Derek Jeter Topps Heritage Red Sox Logo Error Card makes New York Yankee fan’s blood pressure boil (Read: Top Derek Jeter Rookie Cards)
How dare they even print an error card with Jeter associated with the Red Sox!
This is a must for Red Sox fans who love trolling Yankee FANBOYS.
1990 Ken Griffey Jr. Topps Misprint Error Card #336
This Ken Griffey Jr. rookie card can come with a variety of errors.
The card is quite common on eBay and can be bought at a somewhat reasonable price.
Baseball Error Card Values
The exact amount of any given error card is based on a variety of factors such as the condition and numbers of the card.
Most Valuable Baseball Error Card
The most expensive baseball error card is the 1990 Topps Frank Thomas No Name On Front Error Card RC #414. This bad boy sold as a PSA 7 via eBay auctions on 8/5/2021 for slightly more than $7,000 (imagine what a PSA 10 would fetch).
Frank Thomas Fan? Check out the Best Frank Thomas Rookie Card Investments
Least Valuable Baseball Error Card
The Billy Ripken F*** Face Error Card should be the least valuable as there are many up for sale at any given time.
If you would like a price estimate of any error card in your collection please email pictures (back and front) to firstname.lastname@example.org.
Baseball Error Cards Complete List
We searched far and wide for a listing of all error cards ever produced in baseball. At first, we didn’t find a dang thing.
But then we stumbled across a terrible-looking website BUT the information in regards to baseball error cards is accurate and simple to access.
Please visit baseballerrors.com/error-cards.php to obtain a list of baseball error cards broken down by set.
Very cool baseballerrors.com! PS work on the site layout as you provide information not available anywhere else only. Cheers!
Must Read: Gold Card Auctions Hot 10
Baseball Error Cards: Buyers Guide and Investment Outlook
Baseball error cards will usually have a high ROI when compared to normal cards due to the rarity of the card.
Although it should be noted an error card does not automatically equate to big dollars as there are many error cards not worth the paper they are printed on.
If you have a baseball error card and would like an estimated value please visit the Gold Card Auctions Discord Service and look for the request value channel, register at https://discord.com/invite/HuDGgad7z4.
Having said that we are always on the lookout for a high-end error card to add to our sports card investment portfolio.
Did we leave any error baseball cards off this list? What are some other error cards from other sports? Comment below!