Dennis Eckersley Rookie Card – Best 3 Cards and Investment Outlook

Dennis Eckersley Rookie Card

One-time World Series champion Dennis Eckersley (10/3/54) pitched for the Cleveland Indians, Boston Red Sox, Chicago Cubs, Oakland Athletics, and St. Louis Cardinals respectively in a decorated 24-year career.

In recent times, “Eck” is also well-known for his broadcasting, helping him to stay relevant with the latest batch of MLB fans.

Here’s a rundown with Eckersley’s best rookie card options, including an investment outlook looking at the next few years.

The Best Dennis Eckersley Rookie Cards

We’ve checked out recent auction data to bring you a trio of the best Dennis Eckersley rookie cards that would make a good addition to your rookie card investment portfolio.


1976 Dennis Eckersley Topps Rookie Card #98 (buy on eBay)

1976 Dennis Eckersley Rookie Card

The 1976 Topps is Eckersley’s only official rookie card, featuring a large image of the pitcher in his Indians jersey. The background features a clear blue sky, making it an iconic piece of 70’s Americana that is well valued by collectors. Look out for issues with coloring, as it tends to be the main flaw with the set.

Hot Investment: Wander Franco Rookie Cards

You’ll also be able to find an O-Pee-Chee version that is identical aside from some French text on the reverse. The O-Pee-Chee has the same number and sells for a similar price.


1976 Dennis Eckersley Hostess Rookie Card #137

Dennis Eckersley Hostess Rookie Card

Perforated edges make it difficult to find mint copies of the 1976 Hostess, which features an image of the player ready to pitch with a few advertising hoardings in the background. It’s not as prestigious as the Topps edition listed above, although the issues with edging make it almost as expensive if you’re looking at high grades.

Eckersley’s Hostess card is clearly another decent investment option, as long as you can find a copy that doesn’t have too many imperfections. 

Hot Rookie Cards: Gold Card Auctions Hot 10


1976 Dennis Eckersley Kellogg’s Rookie Card #19 (buy on eBay)

Dennis Eckersley Kellogg's Rookie Card

Eckersley’s Kellogg’s RC is part of a 57-card ‘3-D Super Stars’ set released by the cereal company back in 1976. As the name suggests, it has a basic 3D image of the player looking straight at the camera, with a red, white and blue striped border.

The addition of a plastic finish means that they’re easy to find in decent condition, as long as they haven’t cracked or chipped over the last 40 years. It’s also one of the few top rookies from the set, as Kellogg’s typically focused on established stars instead of hot prospects at the time.


Dennis Eckersley Rookie Card Value

The most expensive and sought after Eckersley rookie card is by far his 1976 Topps card grade PSA 10 or BGS 10 Pristine Black Label… whoa that would be a nice one to have!

Invest In A Living Legend!: Top-Rated Mike Trout RC


Dennis Eckersley Rookie Card Checklist

  • 1976 Topps #98
  • 1976 Kelloggs #19
  • 1976 Hostess #137


Investment Outlook 

A decorated player that still has ties to the modern game, Eck is a well respected Hall of Famer (2004) with a host of decent rookie options from 1976. 

It’s no surprise considering he was a six-time All-Star in three separate decades, while he even made the MLB All-Time Team back in 1997. It’s hard to find a better pitcher in the history of the sport.

Given the era, these mid-70’s cards are difficult to find in mint condition, which means they’re cheaper if you’re just hoping to finish off your collection with any old copy. However, PSA 9s are valued highly, and gem mint copies will typically sell for thousands.

Of the three rookie cards we’ve listed, the Topps version is clearly the most likely to see a decent return on investment in the next couple of years.

It tends to get the most attention at auction, it’s part of a prestigious set, and it’s not overvalued compared to other famous cards from the ’70s. We’d advise looking for higher grades for the best possible ROI, especially given the issues sometimes found with coloring and centering.

Eckersley’s cards are worth keeping an eye out for, especially if you can snag a couple for a good price.

Investment Rating: BUY

Ownership Disclosure: None

Leave a Comment