Cale Makar Rookie Card – Top Cards, Value, and Risk/Return Analysis


This post contains affiliate links. Read the full disclosure here.

Buy Cale Makar Rookie Cards on eBay

Best Cale Makar Rookie Cards

Cale Makar (30/10/98) is a defenceman who currently plays for the Colorado Avalanche in the NHL. He was selected in the first round of the 2017 Entry Draft, coming in as the fourth choice overall.

He turned pro in April 2019, signing a three-year contract. Makar then went on to score his maiden NHL goal with his first shot in his debut just a day after putting pen to paper.

We’ve provided a checklist for his rookie cards, along with rookie card investment advice and a trio of the most popular Makar RC options that are currently selling at auction. 

Best Cale Makar Rookie Cards 

Here are the three must-own Makar rookie cards at this very moment. 


2019 Cale Makar Young Guns Upper Deck RC #493

Buy on eBay

cale makar rookie card

Upper Deck Young Guns are the must-have rookie cards in the world of the NHL (currently).

Numbered C94, Makar’s Upper Deck Canvas card is worth checking out if you’re looking for a solid investment option.

As with the others we’ve mentioned, there’s an image of him moving on the ice, along with a distinctive borderless design that helps to catch the eye.

The reverse lists his 2018-19 NCAA stats, with a zoomed-in image of the picture found on the front.

There’s no signature or player patch, but Young Guns cards are always popular with collectors.

Ungraded versions are currently selling for anywhere from $80 to $120, making it a good mid-tier choice with the potential for gains in the future.


2019 Cale Makar Upper Deck Artifacts RC #161

Buy on eBay

Cale Makar rookie card

His Artifacts card may contain player worn material that can be seen on the front, instantly upping the value. There’s a full-length image of the player in his Avs uniform, with a large border for his name and a Rookie label along the outside.

As well as his NCAA stats, the reverse has basic information and a guarantee for the player patch.

Red, Blue, and Gold versions have all recently sold for roughly $20, which is somewhat understandable considering the large print run.

For example, the Gold version with a patch is numbered to 499, while a red border with no patch has 398 others up for grabs.

It’s no coincidence that a Green Border (99) recently sold for $55.


2019 Cale Makar Upper Deck Trilogy Silver Foil RC #81

Buy on eBay

Cale Makar upper deck rookie card

This Upper Deck Trilogy card is another that is always popular at auction. One recently sold for just over $150, after amassing 86 bids by collectors fighting it out for the chance to get a signed piece of rookie memorabilia.

The card features Makar making his way through the ice with his stick at the ready. A signature is the main reason for the interest, as well as parallels which are numbered to 249.

As with the card above, there’s no quote on the back. There’s a typical list of basic stats like height and weight, but nothing else of note. 

If you hadn’t guessed, you’re mostly paying for the signature.


2019 Cale Makar Black Diamond Rookie Gems RC

Buy on eBay

UD Black Diamond Cale Makar rookie card

Available in a range of different colors and parallels, Makar’s Black Diamond cards are worth checking out if you’re looking for a solid investment option at the lower end.

Top Hockey Investment: Wayne Gretzky Rookie Cards

As with the others, there’s an image of him on the ice, along with a distinctive border that catches the eye.

A parallel with an on-card signature recently sold for just under $200, while a Blue version (numbered to 99) went for under $70. It’s a smaller investment, which is easier to swallow if you’re aiming to pick up multiple cards before his career really takes off.


2019 Cale Makar Upper Deck SP Game Used Draft Day Auto Patch /35 RC #DDM-CM

Buy on eBay

2019 Cale Makar Upper Deck SP Game Used Draft Day Auto Patch

This is one of the hardest Cale Makar cards to find and it commands a high price.

On the left side of the card is a photo of Makar on draft night, wearing his Avalanche draft cap. The main feature of the card is a large patch, and each card has a different letter from Makar’s last name.

In addition to the patch, Makar’s autograph is placed on top of it and the combination of those two features make this a very special card.

With the print run limited to only 35 cards, it will be tough for collectors to get their hands on this one.


Cale Makar Rookie Card Checklist 

Cale Makar Rookie Card Checklist 

Here’s a checklist with a roundup of Makar’s many RCs. 

(As a carryover rookie from last season, his cards will appear throughout 2020.). This means that they’re coming out right now, with further Upper Deck sets are due to come out until late April. 

Top-Rated Hockey Card Investment: Connor McDavid Rookie Cards

This means that we can’t provide a full list yet, but here are some of Makar’s rookie cards that have already been released;

  • 2019 O-Pee-Chee Cale Makar RC #528.1
  • 2019-20 O-Pee-Chee – Glossy Rookies Cale Makar RC #R-1
  • 2019 Upper Deck Artifacts Cale Makar RC #161
  • 2019 Black Diamond Rookie Gems Cale Makar RC
  • 2019 Upper Deck Canvas Cale Makar RC #C94
  • 2019 Upper Deck Exquisite Collection Cale Makar RC
  • 2019 Upper Deck Fall Promotion – Victory Rookies #V-1
  • 2019 Upper Deck – Instant Impressions Cale Makar RC
  • 2019 Upper Deck MVP Cale Makar RC #247
  • 2019 UD Overtime Cale Makar RC #60
  • 2019 Upper Deck Parkhurst Cale Makar RC #275
  • 2019 Upper Deck Parkhurst – Prominent Prospects – Gold Autographs Cale Makar RC #PP-10
  • 2019 Upper Deck Rookie Autographs Cale Makar RC #RSCM
  • 2019 UD Rookie Tribute Cale Makar RC #1
  • 2019 Upper Deck Rookie Signatures Cale Makar RC #20
  • 2019 UD Tim Hortons Collector’s Series Cale Makar RC #46
  • 2019 Upper Deck Trilogy Cale Makar RC #147
  • 2019 Trilogy: Silver Cale Makar RC #81
  • 2019 UD Portraits Cale Makar RC #P-50


Cale Makar Rookie Card Value

Cale Makar Rookie Card Value

The most expensive Cale Makar RC is the 2019 Upper Deck Young Guns #493 Exclusives Cale Makar RC Rookie (graded at a BGS 10 or PSA 10).

If you are looking to buy a piece of Makar for your investment stash but want advice please email us at or slide into our DMs on Facebook!

Looking for an estimated value in regards to your Cale Makar RC? Email and we will provide an estimated value of the card.


Cale Makar Rookie Card: Buyer Rating and Investment Outlook

It’s true that Makar was recently snubbed in the All-Star game, which will have an impact on his overall prices in the short term. Regardless, if he carries on in his current form he’s likely to be recognized as one of the key players in the league this season.

ESPN has noted that Makar has been the front-runner for the Calder Trophy so far, highlighting his progress during his first year of competition in the NHL.

Of course, the sheer number of options serves to dilute the value of his rookie cards to some degree, but there are still a number of versions that are already starting to increase in price as he continues to defy his critics.


Sports Card Investor - Trusted, sports card investor dedicated to maximizing sports card portfolio profits. Part-time contributor to Chicago, NBC,,, and the Washington


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here