This post contains affiliate links to include the eBay Partner Network which may earn a commission. We truly appreciate your support.

brett baty rookie card values


The New York Mets drafted Brett Baty with the 9th overall pick in the 2019 MLB June Amateur Draft from Lake Travis HS (Austin, TX). Brett is a force to be reckoned. The Scouts claim he can hit for power and plays excellent defense at the hot corner.


Picking up a few Brett Baty rookie cards now would be a wise play at this stud has all the talent in the world and appears to be the next big thing in the Big Apple. 

Many fans arrive early to watch Brett Baty partake in batting practice as he can quit the show. This “batting practice” showstopper has yet to see this translate to huge numbers at the plate, but scouts feel this is only a matter of when and not if.

Best Football Card Hobby Boxes Under $300
10 Best Football Cards To Buy Under $1000
Rookie Cards That Could Double Your Money This Year
Best Jasson Dominguez Rookie Cards

Baty works well in all fields utilizing a smooth swing from the left side. He typically has a slight issue staying behind the ball and making solid contact off the bat, and when he doesn’t, he can still work a walk via Brett Baty’s scouting report.

Best Rookie Cards

Below are the top 5 Brett Baty rookie card investments we would recommend. Please email with any questions you have surrounding his cards and investment strategies.


#1. 2019 Bowman Chrome Draft Auto RC #CDABB


2019 brett baty bowman chrome rookie card auto

Best overall card in terms of ROI.


#2. 2019 Bowman Chrome Sapphire RC #CDABB


2019 brett baty bowman chrome rookie

A spectacular looking card but rare.


#3. 2022 Bowman Chrome Prospect Rookie Auto /10 Topps SSP #NSCCP-BB

2022 brett baty bowman sp rookie card

This rare Bety Bowman SP RC might be number one if it wasn’t for the fact it is almost impossible to find to purchase. If you do see it, please make a bid and thank us late.



brett baty rookie card values

The most valuable Brett Baty rookie cards sold to date are the 2019 Bowman Draft Gold Wave Refractor 1st Auto #/50 which cashed in at $478 and 2019 Bowman Chrome Auto Purple Refractor #/250 RC #CDA-BB which sold for $432 (both via eBay auctions in June of 2022).



  • 2020 Bowman’s Best Best of ’20 Autographs #B20BTY
  • 2019 Bowman Chrome Sapphire RC #CDABB
  • 2019 Bowman Chrome Draft Auto RC #CDABB
  • 2019 Leaf Valiant Purple RC
  • 2019 Bowman’s Best RC #TP-29
  • 2019 Prizm Auto RC
  • 2019 Panini Red White Blue Prizm DP #21
  • 2020 Bowman Platinum SP #’d Prospect Autos
  • 2021 Leaf Trinity Rookie Shea LOGO Patch Auto RPA XRC
  • 2021 Bowman Chrome Prospects Refractor #BCP-237


Investment Outlook

It all depends on converting that “batting cage power” into real life. If Baty can turn his dreamlike raw pop into actual game power, New York could have its next long-term third baseman and one that have not seen the likes of since a Mr. David Wright.

Categorized in: