Best 5 Hockey Cards to Buy Now (Superior Investments)


This post contains affiliate links. Read the full disclosure here.

best hockey cards to invest in now

While hockey may not be as popular in the United States as the other major sports leagues, the game still has a growing following that is eager to buy sports cards.

On top of the game’s growing nature in America, the game has a legion of devoted, passionate fans that live just across the border in Canada.

Related: Must-Have Rookie Cards

Demand for hockey cards has been rising throughout the COVID pandemic just like the rest of the sports, and as the league continues to grow, we can expect to see new consumers entering the market and continuing to help drive prices up.

These five cards are all some of the best to invest in for collectors who want exposure to hockey cards, and they span all the different eras of the league. From the 1951-52 Parkhurst Gordie Howe representing the early stages of the game to the 2005-06 Upper Deck “The Cup” Alexander Ovechkin and Sidney Crosby cards representing the modern game, hockey cards have changed a lot, but they all are still valuable for a variety of different reasons.

Investors who are looking to get into hockey cards should determine if they want to go for a more modern card or a vintage card. The modern cards, such as the Alexander Ovechkin and Sidney Crosby cards on this list, come with autographs and patches that help give the card unique features that keep the price high.

Instead of autographs and patches, the value of vintage cards come from the lower quantity available and the icons that are pictured on the cards. These cards can be tough to find in good condition because of their age but in strong condition, they can be very valuable.

Top-Rated Rookie Card Investment With Huge ROI Potential
Justin Herbert (The Next Brady?)
Joe Burrow (The Next Manning?)
Jasson Dominguez (The Next Babe Ruth?)
Wander Franco (Top Prospect in MLB)

Grading is another key factor when determining whether an investment is suitable. Ungraded cards will be available for a lower upfront cost but with that comes the risk that they do not receive the grade that you may wish for.


1979 Wayne Gretzky O-Pee-Chee RC #18

Buy on eBay

wayne gretzky rookie card

Wayne Gretzky is not only the most dominant hockey player of all time; he may be the most dominant athlete of all time. Gretzky absolutely demolished the record books during his playing days as he used his uncanny hockey sense to stay two steps ahead and control the game on the ice like a puppet master.

Perhaps one of the greatest stats in all of the sports is that if you removed all of Gretzky’s goals, in which he ranks first in NHL history with 894, he would still be the league’s all-time point leader with just his assists.

Trending: Best Shaq Lakers Card

This 1979 O-Pee-Chee Wayne Gretzky is one of the most iconic hockey cards ever made and commands a high price because of it. The signature rookie card of the face of the sport will always be a card that is in high demand and a great option for investors.

This card can be tough to find in good condition as the blue border can lend itself to chipping easily. It was also a card that was counterfeited often and investors who are looking to purchase this card should ensure that it has been checked over by a reputable source before buying.


1985 Mario Lemieux O-Pee-Chee RC #9

Buy on eBay

Mario Lemieux was a skilled bully as he would punish smaller defenders with his size while dancing gracefully around the behemoths who would be coming for his head. Lemieux’s career would be cut short due to a multitude of health issues, yet he still managed to have one of the most successful NHL careers ever.

Related: Best Mario Lemieux Rookie Cards

This card shows Lemieux in the black Pittsburgh Penguins jersey of the time as he waits for play to begin. Investors should look at this card or its Topps counterpart if they want to add a “Super Mario” card to their collection.

This card can be hard to find in pristine conditions as it tends to have some printing issues such as being off-centered or having poor edges.


2005 Alexander Ovechkin Upper Deck “The Cup” RC

Buy on eBay

2005 Alexander Ovechkin Upper Deck The Cup

When Alexander Ovechkin and Sidney Crosby entered the NHL in the post-lockout 2005-06 season, it marked the beginning of a new era for the league. Since then Ovechkin has proven himself to be one of the deadliest snipers in hockey history as he has constantly terrorized goalies with his howitzer of a shot.

Related: Best Upper Deck Young Guns Cards of All-Time

The Upper Deck “The Cup” set has changed the hockey card industry as it was the first set to create a true high-class, premium product. In addition to pushing the boundaries of how premium a product they could release, this set had the benefit of having a legendary rookie class that was made possible by the loss of the 2004-05 season to a lockout.

Ovechkin has solidified himself as one of the greatest of all time and the numbers that he has managed to put up in the modern era are astounding. When adjusting for how the game has evolved it becomes clear that Ovechkin has found a way to put pucks in the back of the net at a rate that barely anyone has.


2005 Sidney Crosby Upper Deck “The Cup” RC #180 

Buy on eBay

sidney crosby rookie card

A child phenom, “Sid the Kid” has held the expectations of an entire country on his shoulders from a very young age. Somehow, he has not only accomplished everything expected of him but he has surpassed those lofty goals and established himself as one of the most important Canadian hockey figures of all time.

Crosby has achieved remarkable success at both the NHL and international levels as he has won multiple Stanley Cups and Olympic gold medals.

Best Investment: Tom Brady Rookie Cards

This card comes from the same set as the Alexander Ovechkin card mentioned above and the two are similar in plenty of ways. They are both luxury cards, adorned with an autograph as well as a jersey patch.

Crosby is one of the best options for investors because of the large aura around him and his celebrity status in Canada. He is one of the most popular players to ever play the game and is an icon for an entire generation of hockey players.


1951 Gordie Howe Parkhurst RC #66

Buy on eBay

best hockey cards to buy now

The oldest card on this list, this Gordie Howe rookie card belongs to the legendary 1951-52 Parkhurst set. This collection of cards is considered one of the first sets of modern hockey cards and includes several different key rookies of future Hockey Hall of Famers.

Top-Investment: Kobe Bryant Rookie Cards

Investing in this card would be a good idea for collectors who are looking for a premium product and can appreciate the history behind a card like this. The combination of the significance of the Parkhurst set and the icon pictured on the card make this a very desirable card that will command high prices even in moderate conditions. Gordie Howe doesn’t have the nickname of “Mr. Hockey” for nothing as the man is synonymous with the great game.

Investors who are more interested in vintage cards will definitely find themselves attracted to this card as it doesn’t have the fancy bells and whistles that some of the other cards on this list do. No autographs, no jersey patches, just a historic card that has derived its value through time and aura.


Best Hockey Cards To Buy Now: Investment Outlook

All five of these cards would make great investments as they are some of the best hockey cards. Advanced collectors and novices alike should look carefully into purchasing some of these cards for their portfolios.

Investment Rating: Strong Buy (4.8 out of 5)

Best Hockey Card To Buy: Wayne Gretzky OPC RC

All of the cards shown above make excellent long-term investments and should all outperform your average stock over the next 10 to 20 years… in particular, the Wayne Gretzky rookie card.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here