Aaron Rodgers Rookie Cards: One Of The Most Undervalued Investment on Earth?

0

GoldCardAuctions.com is a participant in the eBay Affiliate Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to eBay.com. We deeply thank you for any purchases you make via these links. Our top card investments can be found here. God Bless - Tommy

are-aaron rodgers rookie cards undervalued investment

*This is one point of view in regards to the current value of Aaron Rodgers’s rookie cards. We enlisted our top writers to give their opinion on the subject. Here is Joshua Cameron. Check back later for the next write-up.

Aaron Rodgers grew up in Chico, California, where he became a standout quarterback at Pleasant Valley High School. Although Rodgers put up record numbers for Pleasant Valley High School, he wasn’t highly recruited and didn’t receive any Division I scholarships before enrolling at Butte College in Oroville, California.

BUY AARON RODGERS ROOKIE CARDS NOW

After Rodger’s success at Butte College, he was recruited to play at the University of California. After breaking numerous records at Cal, Rodgers was voted as a finalist for the 2004 Heisman Trophy.r

The Green Bay Packers selected Aaron Rodgers with the 24th overall selection in the 2005 NFL Draft, the second quarterback took after Alex Smith was selected first overall.

Rodgers took a back seat to the legendary Green Bay Packers quarterback and NFL Hall of Famer Brett Favre for the first three seasons of his NFL career before earning the starting role.

Related: Top Brett Favre Rookie Card Investments

Since Rodger’s 4th NFL season, his first season as the Packers starting quarterback, Rodgers quickly became the most proficient quarterback in the league. In 2010, Rodger’s led the Packers to a 10-5 record and captured Super Bowl 45.

Throughout his 17-year NFL career, Aaron Rodgers has been one of the most dominant quarterbacks in the league behind his accuracy and efficiency. Despite Aaron Rodger’s accomplishments, his rookie cards have flown under the radar for a quarterback of his caliber and remain undervalued.

Having said that, this article unveils the most valuable Aaron Rodgers rookie cards, along with his most expensive base rookie cards. What’s more, we’ll compare Aaron Rodgers and Tom Brady’s NFL careers while breaking down the values of both their rookie cards to determine if collectors are overlooking Rodger’s rookie cards.

 

The Most Valuable Aaron Rodgers Rookie Card Investments

To preface Aaron Rodger’s top five rookie cards, you’ll notice that four of his top five most valuable rookie cards emerged from 2005 SP Authentic, released by Upper Deck on January 3, 2006. Should you be interested in chasing Aaron Rodger’s rookie cards from the set, hobby boxes of 2005 SP Authentic are listed on eBay for $1,200.

The lone card in the top five not from 2005 SP Authentic appears in 2005 Bowman Chrome, released just two weeks after the 2005 SP Authentic set. A 2005 Bowman Chrome hobby box fetches about $600 on eBay. Without further ado, let’s delve into Aaron Rodger’s top five most valuable rookie cards.

 

1. 2005 SP Authentic Aaron Rodgers Rookie Authentics Patch Autograph NFL Logo Rookie Card #252

BUY AARON RODGERS ROOKIE CARDS NOW

Each 2005 SP Authentic hobby box comprised 24 packs of five cards, emphasizing two autographs, two serial numbered Rookie Authentics and one rookie patch autograph card.

Aaron Rodgers most valuable rookie card emerged from 2005 SP Authentic as a Rookie Authentics Patch Autograph NFL Logo. As if obtaining Rodger’s game-worn jersey featuring the NFL logo and his autograph aren’t enough, this iconic card is also serial-numbered 1-of-1. 

A collector merited a BGS 9.5 for the card’s condition and a BGS 10 for Rodger’s autograph. On November 1, 2020, a collector purchased Rodger’s iconic rookie card for $229,200 through Goldin Auctions.

As Aaron Rodger’s 2005 SP Authentic Rookie Authentics Patch Autograph NFL Logo rookie card is limited to only one copy, it remains his most valuable rookie card and holds a tremendous amount of value.

 

2. 2005 SP Authentic Aaron Rodgers Rookie Authentics Patch Autograph Rookie Card #252

Like Aaron Rodger’s most iconic rookie card, his second most valuable rookie card is also from 2005 SP Authentic. One of the set’s highlights is the appearance of Rookie Authentics Patch Autograph cards, limited to 799 or less. As such, Rodger’s Rookie Authentics Patch Autograph is serial-numbered to 99.

Rodger’s 2005 SP Authentic Rookie Authentics Patch Autograph rookie card is fittingly serial-numbered 12/99, signifying Rodger’s jersey number since he entered the NFL.

On March 7, 2021, a collector purchased a PSA 9 Aaron Rodger’s Rookie Authentics Patch Autograph rookie card at Goldin Auctions Winter Auction for $107,010. While Rodgers Rookie Authentics Patch Autograph rookie card merited a PSA 9, according to PSA’s population report, four cards have received a PSA 10 yet to be sold at auction.

Rodger’s Rookie Authentics Patch Autograph rookie card has an average sale price of $10,043.50, with the most valuable card after this one fetching $12,000 back in July 2019. 

While Rodger’s second most valuable rookie card carries a much higher print run than his top rookie card, this particular Rookie Authentics Patch Autograph rookie card highlighting Rodger’s uniform in the serial number caused this card to skyrocket in value.

 

3. 2005 SP Authentic Aaron Rodgers Rookie Authentics Gold Patch Autograph Rookie Card #252

The Upper Deck theme continues with Aaron Rodger’s third most valuable card also from 2005 SP Authentic. 

Rodger’s rookie card is too a Rookie Authentics Patch Autograph card, but this time around, it’s a parallel card, serial-numbered to 25. Rodger’s patch highlights the iconic Green Bay Packers’ colors of green, gold, and white.

Graded by Beckett, Rodger’s Rookie Authentics Patch Autograph rookie card received a BGS 9.5 for the card’s condition and a BGS 10 for his autograph.

At the 2021 Goldin Elite Auction on January 31, 2021, Rodger’s Rookie Authentics Patch Autograph parallel rookie card summoned $67,200.

 

BUY AARON RODGERS ROOKIE CARDS NOW

 

4. 2005 Bowman Chrome Aaron Rodgers Gold Refractors Autograph Rookie Card #221 

With a quick change of scenery, Aaron Rodger’s next most valuable rookie card surfaced from the 2005 Bowman Chrome football set, released on January 17, 2006. Bowman issued 18 packs of four cards in each hobby box, containing one NFL rookie card in each pack and one autographed card in each hobby box.

2005 Bowman Chrome emphasizes various parallel cards, though none more limited than the Gold Refractor cards, limited to just one copy. With that said, Aaron Rodger’s rookie card from 2005 Bowman Chrome is an autographed Gold Refractor, serial-numbered 1-of-1.

Aaron Rodger’s Gold Refractor from 2005 Bowman Chrome received a BGS 8 for the card’s quality and a BGS 9 for the clarity of Rodgers autograph. On January 31, 2021, featured at the same auction as Rodger’s Rookie Authentics Patch Autograph parallel rookie card, Rodger’s Gold Refractor autographed rookie card sold for $66,000.

Should you wish to purchase a 2005 Bowman Chrome football hobby box to chase other Aaron Rodgers rookie cards, it will run you roughly $600 on eBay.

 

5. 2005 SP Authentic Sign of the Times Gold Autograph Rookie Card #SOTAR

Reverting back to 2005 SP Authentic, Aaron Rodgers’ fifth most expensive card is his Sign of the Times Gold autograph rookie card.

Each Sign of the Times gold parallel card from 2005 SP Authentic is serial-numbered to 25.

Aaron Rodger’s Rookie Authentic gold parallel rookie card received a PSA 10, firmly establishing its value as one of his most coveted rookie cards.

In November 2021, a collector fetched Aaron Rodger’s Rookie Authentic gold parallel rookie card for $35,000, rounding out his top five most valuable rookie cards.

More Good Reads

50 Most Epic Michael Jordan Basketball Cards
Best Trading Card Boxes to Buy (best of the best)

 

Recapping Rodger’s Top 5 Most Valuable Rookie Cards

While Aaron Rodger’s top two most valuable cards both exceeded six figures, Rodger’s rookie cards significantly dipped in value after that. According to Goldin Auctions, after Rodger’s top five most valuable cards, none of his rookie cards surpass $28,800 while quickly descending into the teens. At this point, it appears Aaron Rodger’s rookie cards aren’t getting the praise they deserve.

 

Top 5 Most Valuable Aaron Rodgers BASE Rookie Cards

When it comes to football trading cards, the rookie cards of quarterbacks typically retrieve the most money. As we now turn our attention to Aaron Rodger’s top five most valuable base rookie cards, the prices seem too good to be true, especially for a quarterback of his nature.

Disclaimer: We’ve utilized data strictly from PSA for each of Aaron Rodger’s top five most valuable base rookie cards.

 

1. 2005 Topps Chrome Aaron Rodgers Rookie Card #190

The 2005 Topps Chrome football set celebrated Topps’s 50th anniversary of producing football cards. Topps issued 2005 Topps Chrome in September 2005 in a 275-card base set, containing 24 packs of four cards. The rookie subset embraced cards 166 to 275, with Aaron Rodger’s base rookie card numbered 190 in the checklist.

According to PSA’s population report, Rodger’s 2005 Topps Chrome base rookie card has a total population of 1,070 cards, including 237 cards obtaining a PSA 10.

The average sale of a PSA 10 Aaron Rodger’s 2005 Topps Chrome base rookie card is $4,336.77, with a Sports Market Report (SMR) value of $4,000.

When weighing all 479 sales of all grades of Rodger’s 2005 Topps Chrome base rookie card, it totals $442,381, with the average sale of his base rookie card being $923.55.

On January 20, 2021, Rodger’s 2005 Topps Chrome base rookie card fetched $5,620, an all-time high for any of his base rookie cards.

 

2. 2005 eTopps Aaron Rodgers Rookie Card #57

Topps launched the eTopps concept in 2000, issuing new sports cards to collectors weekly. Topps limited the print run and prices of eTopps cards, termed IPOs, or initial player offerings.

The print runs for each card ranged from a few hundred to several thousand. Collectors had the option of receiving the physical card or keeping them in a Topps climate-controlled vault.

Unfortunately, the eTopps concept faced countless problems due to website difficulties, server issues, and printing delays back in the early 2000s. However, Topps brought back this concept in 2016 with Topps Now, essentially the same idea as eTopps, though because of advanced technology, the Topps Now platform flourishes.

Like eTopps, Topps Now takes a similar approach with a print-on-demand method, meaning while Topps sets the card’s price, the print run is often determined by how many collectors purchase the card.

Considering Rodger’s 2005 eTopps base rookie card, PSA’s population report reveals a total of 63 cards, including 24 obtaining a PSA 10. The average price of Rodger’s 2005 eTopps rookie card is $382, and the SMR price sits at $700. 

Nonetheless, on October 3, 2021, at Goldin Auctions’ September Card and Memorabilia Auction, Rodger’s eTopps card fetched $1,560, setting a record for Rodger’s 2005 eTopps rookie card.

 

3. 2005 Bowman Aaron Rodgers Rookie Card #112

The 2005 Bowman football set was issued on January 1, 2005, a few weeks before the 2005 Bowman Chrome set.

2005 Bowman issued a 280-card base set and circulated 24 packs of 10 cards in each hobby box. The first 165 cards of 2005 Bowman highlighted NFL rookies, including Aaron Rodger’s rookie card.

Aaron Rodger’s 2005 Bowman rookie card exhibits 878 cards in PSA’s population report, including 155 PSA 10’s. Although PSA’s SMR Report estimates Rodger’s rookie card is worth $800, collectors have purchased Rodger’s 2005 Bowman rookie card at an average cost of $909.17, with the highest price receiving $1,400. When combining all 342 sales from PSA, Rodger’s 2005 Bowman rookie card has totaled $40,195.

 

4. 2005 Topps Heritage Aaron Rodgers Rookie Card #344 

On November 22, 2005, Topps revamped its 1958 Topps football set, launching 2005 Topps Heritage. Topps released the 2005 Topps Heritage 400-card set in 24 packs of eight cards.

Aaron Rodger’s base rookie card from 2005 Topps Heritage holds a PSA population of 287, with 119 cards meriting a PSA 10. Collectors have paid an average of $696.29 for a PSA 10, with the highest amount collecting $1,125 back in January 2021.

Although a staggering 41% of collectors received a PSA 10 for Rodger 2005 Topps Heritage rookie card, it remains one of his most coveted base rookie cards.

 

5. 2005 Upper Deck Aaron Rodgers Rookie Card #202 

The 2005 Upper Deck football set circulated 275 cards in 24 packs of eight cards. Rodger’s fifth most valuable base rookie card emerged from the 2005 Upper Deck 50-card rookie checklist.

The population report from PSA unveils a total population of 208 cards, including 68 cards receiving a PSA 10.

The average sale of a PSA 10 featuring Rodger’s base rookie card is $440.57, although the SMR embeds a value of $575. 

On March 20, 2021, Rodger’s 2005 Upper Deck base rookie card sold for $922.50 at Goldin Auctions March Monthly Card Auction.

 

Aaron Rodgers Top 5 Base Rookie Cards in Review

Now that we’ve also revealed Aaron Rodger’s top five most valuable base rookie cards, you may be questioning why his base rookie cards are so moderately valued. 

Aaron Rodgers has been the Green Bay Packer’s franchise quarterback since the 2008 NFL season, yet the combined market value for his top five most valuable base rookie cards is only $10,627.50.

 

The Value of Tom Brady’s Rookie Cards

After reviewing Rodger’s top 10 most valuable rookie cards (overall top five most valuable and top five most expensive base cards), we’ll now shift our attention to Tom Brady and his rookie cards to analyze any discrepancies while focusing on whether Aaron Rodgers rookie cards are undervalued.

Related: 20 Best Tom Brady Rookie Card Investments

 

Tom Brady’s Top 5 Most Valuable Rookie Cards

All of Tom Brady’s five most valuable rookie cards emerged out of the 2000 Playoff Contenders football set. In turn, Brady’s Championship Rookie Ticket rookie card from 2000 Playoff Contenders is home to his most valuable rookie cards. 

2000 Playoff Contenders limited each Championship Ticket parallel card to 100 copies. These 100 copies of Brady’s rookie card are often viewed as the most prestigious football cards of all time.

On June 4, 2021, Brady’s Championship Rookie Ticket rookie card sold for a record-breaking $3,107,372.40 by Lelands Auctions.

Although Brady’s record sale was surpassed by Patrick Mahomes 2017 Panini National Treasures NFL Shield rookie card that garnered $4,300,000 through the PWCC Marketplace, Brady’s Championship Rookie Ticket rookie card is one of the most treasured football cards in the hobby.

The following are the five most expensive transactions of Tom Brady’s Championship Rookie Ticket rookie card:

  1. Sold on June 4, 2021, for $3,107,372.40 by Lelands Auctions
  2. Sold on April 2, 2021, for $2,252,854.80 by Lelands Auctions
  3. Sold on April 24, 2021, for $1,680,000 by Goldin Auctions
  4. Sold on October 24, 2021, for $1,500,000 by Goldin Auctions
  5. Sold on April 6, 2021, for $1,080,000 by Goldin Auctions

Considering Brady’s iconic $3.1 million sale, another massive sale at $2.2 from Lelands, and adding the top three sales from Goldin Auctions, Brady’s rookie card has surpassed the $1 million plateau five times.

According to Goldin Auctions alone, Brady has 15 rookie cards that surpassed six figures, compared to just two of Aaron Rodger’s rookie cards.

 

Brady’s Top 3 Most Valuable Base Rookie Cards

As illustrated, Tom Brady’s rookie cards are among the most valuable football cards in the hobby. Now, let’s examine how Brady’s top three base rookie cards have fared.

Disclaimer: We’ve utilized data strictly from PSA for each of Tom Brady’s top three most valuable base rookie cards.

 

1. 2000 SP Authentic Tom Brady Rookie Card #118

Tom Brady’s most valuable base rookie card emerged from 2000 SP Authentic. The first 90 cards from 2000 SP Authentic are base cards featuring NFL veterans, and the following 60 cards that appear in the Future Watch Rookie checklist are also base cards, though each card is serial-numbered to 1,250.

Tom Brady’s 2000 SP Authentic rookie card has a total PSA population of 581, including 98 PSA 10’s. As per PSA’s population report, Brady’s 2000 SP Authentic rookie card has an SMR price of $45,000 and an average price of $54,075.79. 

However, since Tom Brady has repped the number 12 since his rookie season with the New England Patriots, and this rookie card being serial-numbered 1240/1250, emphasizing Brady’s jersey number, it fetched a record-high $181,200 at Goldin Auctions Winter Auction.

Shockingly, Tom Brady’s 2000 SP Authentic base rookie card is more valuable than Aaron Rodger’s second most valuable overall rookie card.

 

2. 2000 Bowman Chrome Tom Brady Rookie Card #236

2000 Bowman Chrome issued collectors 24 packs of 10 cards in each hobby box, with the set’s highlight undoubtedly Tom Brady’s rookie card. 

Despite a PSA population of 3,688, which is higher than all of Rodger’s top five base rookie cards combined, Brady’s 2000 Bowman Chrome base rookie card still surpasses Rodger’s most valuable base rookie card.

In fact, Brady’s 2000 Bowman Chrome base rookie card is on par with Rodger’s 2005 SP Authentic Sign of the Times Gold autograph rookie card, which is limited to only 25 copies.

In February 2021, Brady’s 2000 Bowman Chrome rookie card sold for $34,999.99, just one penny shy of Rodger’s fifth most valuable overall rookie card.

 

3. 2000 Bowman Tom Brady Rookie Card #236

Like 2000 Bowman Chrome, 2000 Bowman also circulated hobby boxes containing 24 packs of 10 cards. The set fittingly emphasizes the catchphrase “Home of the Rookie Card,” with collectors seeking Brady’s 2000 Bowman rookie card.

Brady’s 2000 Bowman rookie card has an even higher population than his 2000 Bowman Chrome counterpart, with 4,347 cards in PSA’s population.

Although Brady’s 2000 Bowman rookie card endures a lofty population, roughly 10% of collectors received a PSA 10, making it challenging to discover Brady’s rookie card in a high grade.

The SMR price for Brady’s 2000 Bowman base rookie card is $6,800, an average price of $9,471.38, though the highest sale reached $17,400.

With a sale of $17,400, Brady’s 2000 Bowman base rookie card is more valuable to collectors than Rodger’s top five most valuable base rookie cards combined.

Brady’s 2000 Bowman base rookie card has 1,968 sales, valued at a ridiculous $2,785,961.

 

Tom Brady’s Top 3 Base Rookie Cards in Review

As you can see, Tom Brady and Aaron Rodger’s base rookie cards are currently on opposite sides of the spectrum. While Tom Brady entered the league in 2000 and Aaron Rodgers in 2005, the two elite quarterbacks have had similar backgrounds to NFL stardom and comparable statistics, yet Rodger’s base rookie cards are mediocre.

 

Aaron Rodgers vs. Tom Brady

When Tom Brady and Aaron Rodgers ultimately hang up their cleats, they will go down as two of the greatest quarterbacks of all time. However, Aaron Rodger’s rookie cards are consistently not on the same level as Tom Brady’s. 

From here, we’ll analyze the origin stories of Tom Brady and Aaron Rodgers, compare their statistics, and grade both quarterbacks’ NFL supporting cast to determine the reasoning as to why Brady’s rookie cards remain more prevalent than Rodgers.

 

The Beginnings

Tom Brady and Aaron Rodgers NFL careers got off to similar starts.

After being drafted as the 199th overall pick in the 6th round of the 2000 NFL Draft, Tom Brady was the backup to Drew Bledsoe, who at the time was one of the best quarterbacks in the league. In fact, on March 8, 2001, Bledsoe signed the largest contract in NFL history for 10 years, $103 million. Unfortunately for Bledsoe, he suffered a bizarre lung injury during Week 2 of the 2001 NFL season and never regained the starting job as Brady’s legacy began.

Unlike Brady, Rodgers was a first-round draft pick, selected as the 24th overall pick in the 2005 NFL Draft. Rodger’s NFL career began as the second string to Brett Favre, arguably the greatest quarterback in Green Bay Packers history. During Rodger’s first three NFL seasons, Favre led the helm before briefly retiring and becoming the New York Jets starting quarterback. As a result, Aaron Rodger’s legendary NFL career as the Green Bay Packers franchise quarterback began as a 4th-year veteran.

 

The Stats

Two of the most prominent quarterbacks in NFL history are Tom Brady and Aaron Rodgers. Through 22 NFL seasons, including 21 as a starting quarterback, Tom Brady is a seven-time Super Bowl champion, 14-time NFL Pro Bowler, and three-time NFL MVP. In 17 NFL seasons, including 14 under center for the Green Bay Packers, Aaron Rodgers achieved one Super Bowl ring, nine Pro Bowl appearances, and three NFL MVP awards.

Through Week 13 of the 2021 NFL season, Brady has thrown 615 touchdowns, 201 interceptions while throwing 82,9075 passing yards. In his NFL career, Brady’s averaged 265.1 passing yards per game, 1.96 touchdowns, 0.64 interceptions, 64.1 passing percentage, and a 97.6 passer rating.

Through Week 13 of the 2021 NFL season, Rodgers has thrown 435 touchdowns, 93 interceptions, and 54,123 passing yards. Rodgers has averaged 260.2 passing yards per game, 2.09 touchdowns, 0.45 interceptions per game, 65.1 passing percentage, and a 104 passer rating.

While Tom Brady may have more Super Bowl rings and average a mere five more passing yards per game, Rodgers delivers touchdowns at a higher clip, throws fewer interceptions, and has both a higher passing percentage and passer rating. 

To illustrate the accuracy and efficiency of Rodgers, look no further than his 2011 and 2020 MVP seasons. 

In 2011, Aaron Rodgers threw 45 touchdowns versus only six interceptions while completing 68.3% of his passes to obtain a 122.5 passer rating, the highest in NFL history

In 2020, Rodger’s tossed 48 touchdowns compared to five interceptions and completed 70.7% of his passes to earn a 121.5 passer rating, the second-highest in NFL history after his 2011 season. 

Aaron Rodgers is also the only player in NFL history with more than 300 passing touchdowns and fewer than 100 interceptions.

While Brady holds the record for most Super Bowl rings with seven, Aaron Rodgers is a more accurate and efficient quarterback than Brady. 

Although it seems like Brady will compete until he’s 50, when all is said and done, Rodger’s may surpass Brady’s record for passing yards and touchdowns while already having the edge in passing percentage and passer rating.

 

The Supporting Cast

Tom Brady and Aaron Rodgers will be recognized as two of the most legendary quarterbacks of all time. However, the trend continues, as Rodger’s rookie cards are consistently overshadowed by Brady’s.

Although Tom Brady’s seven Super Bowl rings and counting is a number that may persist for decades, he’s had a much stronger supporting cast around him than Rodgers. Through Brady’s first 21 NFL seasons with the Patriots and Buccaneers, his teammates acquired 35 Pro Bowl selections and 19 All-Pro honors. In comparison, Rodger’s teammates have earned 31 Pro Bowl selections and seven All-Pro awards.

 

Are Aaron Rodgers Rookie Cards Undervalued?

After comparing Tom Brady’s career to Aaron Rodgers, it’s baffling that Rodger’s rookie cards aren’t attracting more attention. While it’s evident that Brady’s remarkable NFL career while capturing seven Super Bowl rings is unthinkable, few recognize that Aaron Rodger’s career statistics are more impressive on many fronts.

Through Week 13 of the NFL season, the Tampa Bay Buccaneers are the favorite to win Super Bowl 56 at +500, with the Green Bay Packers tied for the second-highest odds at +700. Football card collectors will view Aaron Rodger’s rookie cards in a new light if he proves himself in the postseason and the Green Bay Packers win the Super Bowl this season.

Are Aaron Rodger’s rookie cards the most undervalued investment on earth? Without a doubt.

Here’s to an NFC Championship showdown between the Tampa Bay Buccaneers and the Green Bay Packers, which could significantly influence the value of Aaron Rodger’s rookie cards.


Learn how to invest in sports cards:

How to Invest in Sports Cards and make Money
Best Cards to Invest In
How to get Sports Cards graded by PSA

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here